small correction to user comments


The user comment is, I think, not quite correct; Sobibor was not the only death camp where there was a revolt. There was alsoone at the Treblinka death camp, also in 1943, and like the Sobibor revolt, sparked by the news of the Warsaw uprising. It's often thought that the victims of the camps went meekly to their fate, so in that sense it's important to remember that in many cases, they fought back, hoping to retreive honour in a place that offered no other options. But to suggest that there was only one revolt -- as earlier, the author of a book on Treblinka, Jean Francois Steiner did -- in other words, that resistance was exceptional, is not true; it sends a message to the future equally as depressing as that sent by the original crime of genocide.

Where can you read about this? Besides Raoul Hillenberg's massive history, there is also Martin Gilbert's "The Holocaust," which is composed almost entirely of first-hand testimony. Gilbert makes it clear that there were many many acts of resistance and rebellion, many of them purely individual, and helpfully lists them in the index to his book under "Resistance", "Courage," and "Defiance." On the individual level, resistance was fairly constant; organized revolts like Sobibor and Treblinka, were rarer.

reply

The uprising at Sobibór was not the only jewish revolt against the Nazis, but as far as I know, it was the only one successful.
It's kinda weird to see that Hollywood haven't shoot a movie about this event. Specially considering how many movies about the holocaust have been made.
The one and only movie about Sobibór that I've seen is that TV movie with Rutger Hauer, not bad but the movie shows its limited budget.
Instead of shooting silly "fairy-tales" a la 'Inglourious Basterds', Why not to make a movie about a real event where the jews in fact defeated the Nazis gaining in the process their freedom? Because the main instigator of the uprising was a communist? or what?

A lot of people have heard about Auschwitz-Birkenau, Treblinka, Warsaw Ghetto, and so on, but few people in comparison have heard about Sobibór.
If the movie is made, lets hope Spielberg keeps his hands far from the project. I was reading an interview with Claude Lanzmann where he mentions his contempt towards Spielberg's 'Schindler's List' and Begnini's 'Life is Beautiful' because is his opinion those movies reduced the horror of the holocaust to scenes of mere shocking value and cheap sentimentalism. And I'm agree with him.

reply

I would like to see a new film about the Sobibor uprising.

It would be valuable to make a reconstruction of the camp and show like it worked,

because there's nothing left and it's hard to imagine.

They should only show the facts and avoid any cheap drama.

Could be a great film.

reply