So bad


So so bad

reply

Agreed.

reply

Wrong. I loved this movie. M Night's best.

reply

Me three. Never understood the hate. This film must have an acquired taste.

reply

I loved it.

reply

it was scary, but the "logic" and the string of coincidences were really stupid if you thought about them

reply

Which coincidences?

reply

I agree. But if it pops up on TV, I still watch it for Mel (and bought the DVD for my Mel collection). What made it so bad for me was the way the actor's were directed to act/speak their dialogue. They were all told to speak in monotone and to deliver all lines flat, with no projecting. Directed to speak their dialogue like they were just reading their lines instead of acting like normal people. But yet, anytime I bring that up, nobody else seems to notice it or says it's not true. It's very true, and it make the movie stupid to me. Had they all been directed to act "normal", the movie would've been much better for me.

reply