Motherhunt/Alan Smithee


I was watching the episode 'Motherhunt' this morning and I noticed that it was directed by Alan Smithee.

Now, I know that Alan Smithee is a pseudonym used by directors when they do not wish their name attributed to a project, either because it is o fundamentally bad or that others have warped their direction beyond their original intentions.

I have already checked out the Alan Smithee page here on imdb and I noticed that on some of the titles directed by Alan Smithee, it also gives the name of the real director too.

I was just wondering if anyone knew the who the real director was for this episode and/or the reason for 'Alan Smitheeing' this episode - the only episode from the entire run to be directed by Alan Smithee.

Too weird to live...
Too rare to die...
God's own prototype...

reply

I have also wondered about this for several years.

If any one knows who directed Motherhunt...Please spill.

Thanks.

reply

I was literally thinking the exact same thing this morning! I've been dying to know myself!






"It's a real burden being right so often." Captain Malcolm Reynolds, Firefly

reply

There are several things that seem "special" about this particular episode. Namely, many high-profile actors from outside the normal Nero Wolfe repertory ensemble. Carrie Fisher, Griffin Dunne, and of course Penelope Ann Miller.

So, there's evidence that since this particular episode features somewhat of an all-star Hollywood cast, that they also had an all-star high-power Hollywood director... and then the producers and that director didn't exactly have the same "vision" of what a Nero Wolfe episode should look like, ergo the "Smithee" credit.

One day, just by coincidence, I happened to watch "Shallow Hal" (That is, the movie, starring Jack Black and directed by the Farrelly Brothers), and "Mother Hunt" one after the other. I was immediately struck by the fact that there are a significant number of supporting cast in common with "Shallow Hal" and "Mother Hunt". Not the least of which is Manon von Gerkan, who while she essentially "joined" the repertory cast, this was her first episode.

I had a fleeting thought. "Farrelly Brothers?" Naahhh... No way! "Farrelly Brothers?" Nah. No.

Then, I watched "Mother Hunt" again...

In the scene where Archie consults with a "local sage" to get directions to Ellen Tenzer's cottage, a HUGE sign on the auto repair garage behind the "sage" reads, "Farrelly Brothers" (!!!)

I swear. Check for yourself. The sign is right behind the sage giving Archie directions.

I'm almost satisfied I've "detected" the director!

reply

Kudos for the great detective work on the “Shallow Hal” and Farrelly Brothers connections, but: Right church, wrong pew. Our man Smithee is Charles B. Wessler, the producer of “Shallow Hal”...and friend of Timothy Hutton/Carrie Fisher/Griffin Dunne, which must be how he got the “Motherhunt” job despite his lack of both experience as a Director and, apparently, familiarity with Nero Wolfe.

According to the March 2002 issue of the Directors Guild of America Magazine (link below), Wessler joined the DGA the same time as Michael Jaffe, the Executive Producer of “Nero Wolfe,” who also had no prior Director experience but was a longtime Nero Wolfe fan with a fine command of his subject. Jaffe directed “The Silent Speaker” in Season Two (wrote the adaptations for “Speaker” and “The Doorbell Rang,” as well), and is so credited on Imdb; Wessler remained without a Director credit because the “Motherhunt” that was initially his went awry and became an Alan Smithee.

http://www.dga.org/news/v26_6/dept_dga_forum_additions.php3

A couple of fellow “Nero Wolfe” fans and I hit on the “Shallow Hal” connection while scratching our heads over the gorgeous but woefully miscast Manon Von Gerkan in “Motherhunt.” Thought the other two of Charlie’s Angels, as we refer to them :-) -- Erinn Bartlett and Brooke Burns — were terrific and spot-on, though.

Thanks so much for the further evidence, Farrelly sign = Farrelly Brothers, which we had totally missed! BTW, another in-joke in “Motherhunt” -- the names of a few female “Nero Wolfe” production team members, e.g., Sharon Doyle (Head Writer/Consulting Producer) and Lindsey Hermer-Bell (Production Designer), are included among the suspected mothers on the working blackboard shown on the screen.

reply

Awesome info. Thanks!

reply

I'm surprised and very happy to see this Nero Wolfe mystery solved -- and I think it really is. Thanks, mark-172 and annetessler, for your sharp eyes and detective work about who directed "Motherhunt." Good job.

reply