MovieChat Forums > Silent Hill 2 (2001) Discussion > Would you survive in Silent Hill?

Would you survive in Silent Hill?


Ok so say you were trapped in Silent Hill instead of James. How far would you get before you got killed? I think I'd make it as far as the apartments before getting shot by Eddie

reply

I would probably survive until that part where Pyramid Head happens for the first time, because eventually I would get tired from running around the room trying to avoid his big sword, then he would chop me and my head will roll onto the floor, then the water would go down, but by then it would be too damn late.

www.myspace.com/daviddanieldavis
www.myspace.com/jamcitymuzik

reply

[deleted]

I'd like to say that i'd be able to handle anything that SH could throw at me, but in all reality i think i'd be seriously wigging out about all the freaky *beep* going on around me. Would be interesting at the very least though!
=================================================
I'm a dyslexic insomniac agnostic...
I lay awake at night, wondering if there is a dog.

reply

Actually,i would love to be in Silent Hill,seriously. I would do the best i could to survive but,you never know where you could get in a fatal situation.




-'' I hate horror movies ''- Demonì

reply

I don't think anyone would ever survive
I mean...you don't have chances in life like James has!,If you die...thats it! you can't just "load"
and also you wont be able to continue,seeing monsters and blood everywhere and dead bodies will make you go crazy no matter what.

and if you do... Eddie will just kill you with one shot.

YOU ARE SOO DEAD!!!

reply

I mean...you don't have chances in life like James has!


Yeah, who throws himself into dark holes where you can't even see the bottom... in at least FOUR different ocasions!!!

reply

If I was armed with guns, knives, all that crap I might beable to make it further than the apartments. But yeah it all depends on what demons are in your past. I dunno what mine would be, but still, might be interesting. I'd have to have atleast one close friend with me though, or I'd just go crazy and shoot myself straight away.

And if I met someone like Eddie or Angela, I'd force them to come along with me anyway, I wouldn't just go on by myself! I'm a wimp, lol! Well, maybe not Eddie.. lol

reply

I'd like to bring a friend along too, but most of them would probably run away or *beep* bricks. I think i need to find some friends that aren't wusses. No-one would even watch the Grudge with me. What's up with that?

I don't know if I'd want Eddie or Angela tagging along, since they're not the most stable people around. Perhaps i could get Ernest to help out. Like a guardian angel of sorts, helping me kick monster ass.

Just for once I'd like to have a competent companion in a SH game (no, Eileen doesn't count). I always thought that would be kinda cool and mix things up a bit. Perhaps it will happen in SH5.

=================================================
I'm a dyslexic insomniac agnostic...
I lay awake at night, wondering if there is a dog.

reply

Maybe I'd like someone like Maria (they'd have to be real, of course) only a male version as I'm a girl. Atleast then I'd have some hot, suave guy there to protect me from the monsters and charm me every once in a while to take my mind off all the hell going on around us.

reply

i could handle silent hill...you just have too be sure not to let out negative energy for it too feed on...otherwise it will use that and turn things against you...

reply

I think I'd fall into a toilet at the begining and drown lmao

Live Forever Or Die Trying

reply

[deleted]

I'd make it to the foggy path, hear the dog noises, then run away crying into my car and drive away.

I'd come back with body armor, a shotgun, 2 handguns, some grenades, maybe a large knife, a floodlight, and a TON of spare ammo.

Then i'd wtfpwn all the monsters. (even pyramidhead cuz i'm smart enough to shoot his soft body instead of his metal helmet like james)

reply

I would end up comitting suicide. Or at least leaving when I see that there are inhuman freaks wandering an unnaturally foggy and deserted town!

Go blu

reply

I agree. As soon as I found the pistol and the bullets, they're going into my brain!

reply

I agree. As soon as I found the pistol and the bullets, they're going into my brain!
lol

Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn

reply

I would survive up until I was attacked by the Pyramid "Brothers". The Abstact Daddy/Door man monster would be hell to, but thank the Konami gods they're slow. Getting back the the brothers, I would tire out mentally and either let myself get killed or give my accasional jumpy nature I'd trip and break my leg.

A legacy is something only mortals leave behind!
My two cents and a nickel!

reply

Honestly, I don't think I could.

"Robin Williams turns me on when he's in his Mrs. Doubtfire costume." -Kilanjo

reply

I probably wouldn't make it far. Maybe with a second person, that could encourage me. Other than that, I think I would just stay at the same place locked in and not even have the courage to get out

*´¨)
¸.·´¸.·*´¨) ¸.·*¨)
(¸.·´ (¸.·´ www.protectseals.org, sign the petition, tnx :-)

reply

I would never make it out unfortunately

'Alright Dexter! Protecting our children!!'

reply

With all due respect, I don't think any of use (including the previous posters) would survive in Silent Hill. Like posters before me, it's all to do with how mentally stable we all are, and even though I know not a single one of you personally, you have to ask yourself are you really THAT strong on the inside? Silent Hill takes your worst fears and past memories, and places you in the center of them. Could you stand to see your best friend dead on the floor? Or how about any of your family members being mutilated before your eyes.
Considering I have had a very tormented and abused childhood, I'm a very weak minded and feeble person, who buckles under the slightest of presser. I would have very bad "demons" awaiting me in Silent Hill. I would personally do all I could to stay in a lit atmosphere and try my best to avoid everyone and anything (Maria was a demon, what makes you think everyone other then yourself in Silent Hill isn't a manifestation as well? Just placed there to mess with you and bring you down further to your inevitable peril.)

I don't honestly say I would have anything to fear from Pyramid Head.. I've done some stupid stuff in my past, but nothing I feel I should be punished for. Pyramid Head was placed into Silent Hill with James because he felt guilty and wished punishment for his sins/wrong-doings....

Just my opinion ^-^

reply

hmm. Well for one I know i probably woudln't make it. not because i have extremely bad demons that i have to live with but i can't react well to pressure and i'm extremely afraid of the dark so that would really screw with me and honestly, WTF!?!?! If I see a monster, I'd probably sh!t a lung out or something. I mean I could fight them but the whole adventure would be too terrifying for me to take. So I'd probably make it as far as the hospital where those hanging monsters are. they would tear me a new vagina.

No one knows what they are or where they've come from...
-silent hill 2

reply

I think you'd be amazed what you can work through if you look it in the eye. One of the worst and most intense combat training I went through, when I had a few moments listening to my battle buddies talking like they were already PTSD, I remarked, "It's just like childhood, only you're psychologically equipped for it." Everyone got quiet. VERY quiet. For almost 15 mins no one said anything, for the rest of the hour after that no one talked more than a couple words in mutters, mostly staring at the ground, and no one looked me in the eye for the rest of the day. I really don't know if it's because what I said really disturbed them, or if they just had to reflect on their own *beep* in their own upbringing.

But that shock training prepared me for real crisis, just like the crap I had to go through as a kid prepared me for that training.

And so far I'm the only one I know who's never had a bad trip, no matter how many times I've stared into the Abyss...

reply

I may die of some bacterial disease in the toilet at the beginning.

Otherwise I think I'd find it pretty hard to kill the first monster if I only had a plank of wood.

reply

[deleted]

simple. I've seen too many scary movies to enter a creepy deserted town.
f^#k that! (runs away)

I'd prob be to freaked to move the very first creatre I see. then it'd kill me.
yeah I doubt any of us would actually survive the town. if you can't make it through the game without being killed, how you gonna survive in real life lol?

reply

I agree with everything said here. If you have a really good imagination and actually place yourself in Silent Hill for a moment, you would know that you will probably freeze at the first unsettling sound in the mist...if not at the first monster that you encounter. It's the way the human mind works...we need some time to process new things, and the living nightmares happening in Silent Hill are simply too much to process, let alone react to in time.

However, I do believe there is a power that can get every normal person here further than he/she is supposed to survive in Silent Hill on normal occasions. Obviously you're not going there to have fun or to pursue happiness...you are going there in search of a loved one. If you really love someone and really focus on this thought and feeling hard enough, you can make the next step in the mist after hearing that creepy sounds that would drive you away normally...hell, you will even pull the trigger when you have to, even though you've never held a gun before, let alone fired one. Probably you will lose your mind in the end, but you will get far...

That is what I would like to believe, I'm not stating it as a fact. I see myself entering Silent Hill and really freezing in place on the path down to the lake through the mist, when you start hearing sounds. However, when I place myself in the same spot, but this time with the thought of someone I love very much, I can actually make one more step...and then one more and one more again. None of us is Rambo, none of us is the Terminator, but when we tell our loved ones that we would do anything for them, some of us actually mean it. It's simply what I like to believe...

reply

It's hard to say. I'd like to think that my adhrenaline would kick in and I'd survive just as long as James or Harry. If I were searching for a loved one too, probably the thought of them would keep me going.
But saying that, I don't know how I'd react to using guns and all the weird noises would severly creep me out. So most likely I'd end up freezing, going mad and eventually turning the gun on myself
Let's just hope I never have to find out...

About 2 months ago....there was this "incident"...involving zombies...in a mansion...

reply

I would almost certainly survive James' nightmares. Not to say I wouldn't be scared, but the majority of the monsters just aren't all that dangerous. Pyramid Head, of course, is the exception. While I am no gunslinger, I do have training with guns and I practice enough to maintain competency. I wouldn't have too much trouble shooting the nurses, manequins, and other "low level" creatures. They don't move very fast and they always come right to you.
The blindly jumping into holes? I don't see myself doing that. I dabble in UrbEx, so the prospect of visiting a place like Silent Hill is intriguing, but even a rabidly enthusiastic UrbExer wouldn't do something as stupid as James does.
Now, should Silent Hill provide me with my own nightmares, I doubt I'd fare so well. The nature of things that scare you is, after all, that they scare you. If I wasn't afraid of my innermost fears, then they wouldn't be my innermost fears, would they?

reply

I would persuade pyramid head to join me in return for a bent needle and some hair, PH would be a good ally. he might accept it but more likely PH would kill me pretty quickly!

reply

Like someone before me has said, I think I would just curl up into the feotal position in the corner and go mental

Or get back in my car and go home.

reply

Since I have virtually no experience with weapons whatsoever (The closest would have to be swinging around my katana sword in my room) I'd probably shoot like Marge Simpson shooting precious antique cans (Hence, I would die pretty quick) That's the thing I always thought was cool about Silent hill games. You're character uses weapons pretty realistically, in the sense that they have no combat training (So they miss their target at times, they seem clumsy at points, play the games on hard and you'll know what I mean) in contrast to Resident evil, where you'll hit you're target a lot of the time with the auto aim (Of course the RE characters are cops and what not, but that's not the point)

I guess like another poster said, it all depends how you look at you're fear in the eye. And this post reminds me of a documentary with F.B.I agent Joe Pistone who infiltrated the Mafia in the 70's-80's. He mentioned how he was close to getting killed by suspecting mobsters at one point but managed to keep his cool because he always thought to himself, "The worst they can do is kill you." I guess someone with a lot of will and an attitude like that could make it through Silent Hill, though I know I couldn't.

reply

[deleted]