Can the Humor of This Movie Be Explained?
I really don't want this to turn into a "You're Dumb for Liking/Disliking This Movie" debate, I am honestly and respectfully just trying to figure out how certain films can be loved by some, but loathed by others.
I remember being a kid in elementary school and watching animal videos in school. If a bear or raccoon fell out of a tree and rolled down a hill, the other kids would be laughing hysterically, while I would be sitting there wondering what was so funny. I was perplexed, wondering if I was missing out on what was actually funny or if the kids who were laughing were just easily amused.
I believe that there are categories of funny that usually work on different levels for different people. A big one is incongruity, such as an arrogant snob farting, or a person making an argument and making an embarrassing typo--especially if it contains an unintentional innuendo. Another is seeing mild misfortune, like someone falling on the sidewalk--which usually gets a bigger laugh if they are carrying something and it breaks. In both of those examples, the humor is found at the mild expense of someone. We don't laugh at major misfortunes, only little things. Nothing more than someone's minor loss of some dignity plus the cost of a pie.
It may be against the law, but I didn't find Bubba Ho-Tep or the Monty Python movies funny. Both were recommended by the same friends. Are there people who liked Bubba Ho-tep but didn't like Monty Python? The only common denominator I can identify between those examples is that they have a gritty, low-budget feel to them and I wonder if that environment helps set the stage for certain folks. I wonder if the humor in them appeals to people of a "humor orientation" different from my own.
I don't find the Three Stooges funny, I don't find physical comedy funny except when performed by John Ritter (he had a style), and old Warner Bros cartoons were cool, but not usually funny (to me). Sometimes a comedy turn-off is when they try too hard. It almost comes across as overly-confident and that can kill humor. Another comedy-killer is condescension. If I feel that the filmmaker is talking down to me or going for the cheap laugh, my emotional reaction is to simply anticipate the next scene and hope it is better.
For example, this quote (and I mean no disrespect, fans, please don't be offended):
"I was dreamin'. Dreamin' my dick was out and I was checkin' to see if that infected bump on the head of it had filled with pus again. If it had, I was gonna name it after my ex-wife Priscilla and bust it by jackin' off. Or I'd like to think that's what I'd do. Dreams let you think like that. Truth was, I hadn't had a hard-on in years."
The quote above gets the following reaction from me:
How unfortunate a dick infection must be. The insult to his ex-wife is kind of funny as it indicates that he has held on to a grudge for years and enjoys a good jab at her when the opportunity arises. I can relate. The talk about hard-on deprivation, which must come from old age, makes me think of Viagra jokes. And I can't help but think this appeals to our inner juvenile. As a result, it reeks of "cheap laugh," for me. I wonder if the Elvis accent and regional colloquialisms add to the "ambience" of the humor, like many Southern sayings do.
Then there is the scene where Elvis is trying to kill the bug. I think we can all relate to the adventures of bug-squishing when it doesn't go well, but I didn't even know that scene was trying to be funny. I have read reviews of Bubba Ho-Tep where that scene was described as THE funniest sequence ever. Suddenly, I felt like I was back in elementary school, once again NOT laughing at that bear cub tumbling down a hill, while everyone else was. I have chased a good many bugs around my apartment, and I usually talk trash to them when I do. "That toilet is your punishment for being ugly. Enjoy your eternity in Sewer Hell. Give my best to toilet-satan." I do that to amuse myself in my own silly way, but I never knew that it would be hilarious for others if they saw it.
What I would like to see in this thread is an explanation, not only of WHAT people found hilarious in this movie, but WHY. I know explaining it often ruins it, but with me, it's already not funny. I just want to satisfy that curiosity. Please explain.