MovieChat Forums > Amen. (2002) Discussion > some one pls explain the ending to me i ...

some one pls explain the ending to me i got confussed on what happened


who died and didnt the guy who hung him self have kids.

reply

As far as I remember the priest as well as the german officer died. And yes, the german officer (= the guy who hung himself) had kids

reply

The priest died in the concentration camp.
The good SS officer was killed and it was staged as a suicide.
The evil SS officer was given asylum in Argentina.

reply

"Whether he [Kurt Gerstein] committed suicide out of despair and guilt in not being able to stop the Holocaust or whether he was murdered by other SS officers in the prison remains a mystery."

http://www.auschwitz.dk/Gerstein.htm

reply

Do you mean the trailer at the end of the film? There was a translation error I believe. It should have said Gerstine was exhonorated for his actions, not resurrected or whatever. You can check out his bio on a holocost website.

reply

[deleted]

'Rehabilitated' also means 'restored in his honour'. It does not imply that he survived.

reply

[deleted]

Had a very difficult time understanding the actors. It was in English, but everyone sounded sorta funny. I almost wished that everyone spoke his/her native tongues. In any case, I got super confused about the ending credits. I thought that he hung himself then the credit said that he was released after 20 years. Rehabilitation, I believe, was a mis-leading word.

My life isn't any better than yours.

reply

[deleted]

I found the way the film ended and tied the loose ends together to be very rushed and a little unsatisfying after the steady pace building up to it.

"People will do anything, no matter how absurd, in order to avoid facing their own soul" - C.G.Jung

reply

I saw the film, couple of year ago, and in French, but I had the impression that he killed himself, was he did eveything he has, as he did have a choice, and wanted to be a witness, to be able to talk about it.
And he is treated like a criminal and a really evil man, when he tried to do his nasty job with as much as little humanity he could.

So not being able to be understand, he killed himself as he was treated as a war criminal.

And yes, the priest died in a concentration camp.

People has critize that movie saying it wasnt objectif, but I think that Costa-Gravas show that its never black or white, like that poor german officer.
(sorry i'm french and my english isnt that good!)

reply

I think he killed himself because when they put him in a seperated cell, they gave him a copy of Court of Denunciation. After reading it, where it was stated he didn't do anything in his power to safe lives & he's a war criminal, there was a look of desparation on Gerstein's face. He already tried all he could & now he was put on trial ?
It never stated clearly about the fate of the priest, who is a fictional character. The doctor whom the Vatican helped to flee to Argentina is fictional as well.

reply

> Had a very difficult time understanding the actors. It was in English, but everyone sounded sorta funny..

I'm a half-deaf / older english speaker. Most dialogue was understandable, esp after repeated rewind/replays of lines, but not all.

For me it would have been much preferred to have closed captioning available while watching the (netflix supplied) dvd.

Ah well, this was still the best of several holocaust movies i've seen.


----
Dr Horrible's Singalong Blog (last words): "Don't worry. Captain Hammer will save us."

reply

It never stated clearly about the fate of the priest, who is a fictional character


It seemed quite clear he died in the camp.

The doctor said "take him away to be with his friends" in the scene at the camp when Gershtein was trying to save the priest with his false papers(paraphrasing the doctor), so the guard dragged him away to be killed.

Later, an inmate in the camp was sorting through the pile of clothing from those who had gone into the gas chamber in the latest group, and he held up the cossack of the priest and inspected it, with the yellow star still affixed to the breast of it.

Then he dropped it into the cart for disposal.

Priest. Dead.

reply

First of all, who knows how to help someone who is confussed? You parody yourself, I only hope that was intentional!!??


The more I think, the more I am?

reply