MovieChat Forums > Fear Factor (2001) Discussion > Animal cruelty issues?

Animal cruelty issues?


I thought the media was pretty strict on this sort of thing these days....so doesn't the eating of live insects for entertainment count?

reply

I was JUST about to say this. Again.

I mean, this show started in 2001!! I cannot believe that they managed to get away with having people eat LIVING CREATURES. (Never mind that anyone was actually capable of doing it. Just watching someone put a live grasshopper in his mouth makes me want to gag and hurl.) I mean, how horrible and unnecessary is that?! Even if you tried to argue, "Well, they don't really feel pain, and it's over very quickly"...just...no. For a GAME show?!?

Those are the "challenges" I could NEVER, EVER do--the "eat this or that vile thing" ones. ESPECIALLY eating bugs/insects, and ESPECIALLY live ones. Can you even begin to imagine putting a moving, wiggling thing in your mouth and crushing it up? I cannot...I cannot imagine it as a remote possibility...I would simply never, ever do it. Bob in a tank full of hundreds of moray eels? Heck yes, I would like to do that! I've snorkeled with sharks and played with stingrays. I adore them. Almost anything else on the show, fine. I'll do it. A lot of it would probably be flat-out fun. But the eating disgusting stuff, and the crunching of living little buggies...never, ever, ever in a million years.

And do they guarantee the contestants that they're not going to like, get sick or poisoned or severely injured or killed by any of these stunts? Or was it trying to be more of a "risky and risque Japanese-esque game show?"


"If you don't have anything nice to say...come sit by me!"

reply



Yep, that's definitely a line for me too. I'll do pretty much anything on a dare, but the eating of disgusting things makes my gut turn over. I'm close to hurling when I step on a decent sized cockroach because of the mess, why the hell would I want the insides of some of the monstrous bugs on this show bursting, fresh and warm, into my mouth? And alive and struggling at that?

As for the cruelty thing, I can kind of see people's disassociation with bugs (not feeling pain like we do?), but I thought that the killing of any animals for entertainment purposes had been a big no-no for a long time. Perhaps, as with fishing and hunting shows, they get a pass because the animals are being eaten?

reply

Yep! I had imagined that my younger brother--who is pretty adventurous, culinarily speaking--might be willing to eat a bug, and considered getting him some (dead) crickets, worms, scorpions, spiders or some such thing, which had been coated in cheddar or sour cream, or embedded in lollipops. Fortunately I decided against it, because when I later mentioned the idea to him, he said he didn't think that even he would be interested in sampling insects.

I really like bugs myself, but the thought of eating one--how they must feel and taste, and the MOVEMENT of living ones--is unbearable. I have no idea how they found people willing to do it.

I've been told that since insects don't have the same kind of nervous system as other animals, they actually don't feel pain, or at least not to the same degree...although I don't know how they can be completely certain. Killing for entertainment is definitely a big no-no in countries like the US, so I'm wondering why I don't recall hearing a big stink from the American Humane Association or anyone else when this show was being produced. I think the shows that involve hunting, fishing, and farm-animal slaughter are accepted because the people on them supposedly do what they do for a living...to sustain themselves and live off the land, and all that. But crushing a live, struggling animal apart with your teeth, even if it's "just a bug," for the chance of winning a game really sounds nothing short of barbaric. o.O To drive it home, they even show you close-ups of the little things moving around, trying to escape the containers, as some are lifted and chewed to bits. SO. NOT. KOSHER.

Personally, I could never hunt or raise animals for slaughter unless they were going to be killed painlessly at an old age for their species...and the only fishing I'll ever do is the catch-and-release I tried a few times as a little kid. So I still don't watch any of the 'Discovery'-esque shows that involve animals destined to be killed by humans, unless they're being euthanized on a veterinary program. Fear Factor can be kinda fun, but the live-bug-eating parts truly repulse me.

ALSO, even some of the other stunts that didn't involve eating things alive still seemed as though they'd be unfairly stressful to the animals recruited for them. E.g., dumping snakes repeatedly onto people so they could then be picked through and thrown out of the tub...two moray eels scooped up and poured into a helmet, then sliding out and dropping into the tank below...etc. For something that's pure entertainment and benefited only humans, they could have been a lot more considerate of these creatures. I feel as though the AHA dropped the ball by not requesting more humane setups.

Again, I'd gladly do any of the non-eating challenges, but I'd be as careful and gentle with the little critters as possible.


"If you don't have anything nice to say...come sit by me!"

reply

Hahahaha hahahaha ha everyone has a price. You guys sound like pansies

reply

I don't think people care too much about bugs, lol. Besides, people in other countries eat bugs. I saw someone eating live grubs on TV one time. I believe he was a native of the Amazon basin.

reply