MovieChat Forums > We Were Soldiers (2002) Discussion > This or Windtalkers?

This or Windtalkers?

posted 8 years ago by leyenda61
3 replies | jump to latest

Haven't seen either or Black Hawk Down or Tbin Red Line. Never heard any reviews saying they were amazing. I guess I am ruined for war movies after having saw Full Metal Alchemist.

-- Sent from my 13 year old P.O.S. Desktop®

[–] SpiltPersonality 8 years ago

This and Blackhawk down are very good military stories. I find Blackhawk down the superior of the two.

Thin Red Line and Windtalkers are both rubish.

[–] GhostRiver 7 years ago

No, your putting Terrance Mallick and John Woo in the same sentence is rubbish. The Thin Red line is out of your league--stick to garbage like this film and Windtalkers

[–] stefanlaur 7 years ago

Windtalkers and this one both are among the worst war movies ever made. Completely one-sided, way too much patriotism, drama(not the good kind) and pathos...