MovieChat Forums > Hornblower: Retribution (2001) Discussion > Question about Archie **SPOILERS**

Question about Archie **SPOILERS**


Why did it take him so long to die? He was shot 6 months previously from the trial, you the the gun wound wouldn't just sit there that long. He would either die in at least a couple of weeks, or live.

reply

[deleted]

Archie was not shot 6 months from the trial. They were at an unknown location at the beginning (ie. 6 months ago) and then stopped at Plymouth and then sailed all the way to the West Indies which could've possibly taken a few months.

reply

What? He was shot at the end of the fight against the Spaniards, when Sawyer and Wellard died, and then died 6 months later at the trial.

reply

No. A considerable amount of time has passed when we first see the Renown in the storm (ie. 6 months ago) and the end of the fight against the Spaniards.

We see the Renown in the storm and then the next scene we're at Plymouth Sound. A month (or maybe longer) could've passed between these two locations.

Then the Renown sails from Plymouth Sound to the West Indies. Sailing from England across the Atlantic Ocean south to the West Indies would definitely take up 5 weeks at least.


reply

Exactly. So don't you think it's wierd that it took him so long to die?

reply

Look at it this way.

Ship in storm = 6 months ago

I'll take a wild guess and say they took 2 months to reach Plymouth.

Ship docks at Plymouth Sound = 4 months ago

They could've taken a week to replenish supplies, repairs,etc..

Ship set sails from Plymouth = 3.75 months ago

Considering how ill-disciplined the crew of the Renown were, I don't think they'd sail very fast... plus any storms, enemy ships they encountered across the Atlantic Ocean.. I'll say they take about 3 to 4 months to reach Samana Bay (let's say 3 and a half months)

Ship reaches Samana Bay = 1 week ago (0.25 months ago)

Capture of the fort, battle with slaves could've took a day.

Battle onboard the Renown(ie.Archie shot) = 6 days ago

Archie did not take 6 months to die. He probably died a week or maybe 10 days after he was shot.

reply

ARCHIE LIVES!

*giggles*

reply

Indeed! XD

Sometimes standing still can be the best move you'll ever make.

reply

[deleted]

I thought Jamie's character one BSG was named Lee, not Archie... O.o

Sometimes standing still can be the best move you'll ever make.

reply

Put it this way; Bush was still raw injuries when Archie died, therefore it can't have been more than a few weeks after the battle.

reply

I agree with you .six month before , is when we see Horatio ,archie.... in the rainy night at the beginning of "mutiny "(in the flash-back).

reply