I just watched the movie and I have to say I see exactly what you're trying to say here and I agree about how there isn't a fact and your opinion makes complete sense to me.
The distinction here is there is overwhelming proof to the alien possibility, but the movie seems intent on it not being definitive proof. It's as though it all but seals the final nail, but then goes out of its way to be indirect in what you're led to believe about Bess and the entire concept of possession never even being mentioned by the movie. To me the way it ended stood out similarly to how it started and came across fairly obvious with how much whimsy it had suggesting the super natural.
There is without a doubt more evidence Prot was a real alien, as evidence becomes introduced and never has explanations that definitively disprove it. Instead the movie takes you on a twist to discovering Robert. There is then much less convincing evidence that Robert is crazy or tricking everyone with how he acts in hypnosis, the hint dropped about how he was always very smart, and importantly how Robert resented working at a Butcher's and yet it was Prot that mentioned the fruit alone being worth his visit. In a sense you can see these discoveries as purposefully misleading coincidences towards the alien argument that isn't disproven yet. But then why only at this point does the lesser evidence have to be misleading?
I'm not even so sure myself, or that it's supposed to be whatever the audience thinks it is. Rather I see the journey the movie puts you on. It's really more intent on that twist, and essentially trying to seal the whole overall whimsical tone by suggesting, heavily suggesting, that the twist was a fake out. The movie seemed very preoccupied with its tone and all that xylophone music lol. I actually highly suspect anyone insisting on any obvious facts is giving the movie more credit as a sci fi than it really was dealing with compared to the drama. And so if I had to pick a side I'd agree with your opinion because it fits the style of the movie much better.
reply
share