MovieChat Forums > American Gun (2002) Discussion > I have had a massive brain fart, help!!

I have had a massive brain fart, help!!



We find out near the end that Martin killed daughter Penny by accident. So the gun was in the house THEN. The police confiscated the gun, and it later was sold to a wholesaler....etc...on an on to different owners...then he tracks it down to his granddaughter Mia. It's the same gun, right? How did she get it? I thought she had taken it from the drawer before she left home, but then that would mean her mother Penny was accidentally killed before she left home, and the gun had to have remained in the home (but it was confiscated by the police), not to mention that she also would have known of her mom's death already. I have had a massive brain fart and need help on the sequence of events.


Mountain Man

reply

Mia bought the revolver at a pawnshop. But, I kinda lost track of it myself after the black kid shot his girlfriend's lover on the basketball court, then turned the gun on himself. Another crooked cop selling from his trunk?

At the beginning, when he met his grandaughter Mia in the dinner, she went to the restroom. In a revisit to the same scene toward the end of the movie, Martin decides to put more money in Mia's purse. Martin finds the .357 that Mia had just bought at the pawnshop in her purse and he takes it. He keeps the gun in a drawer, then his daughter Penny goes back to the scene of the mugging for the shopping bag, comes back and then Martin shoots her.

reply

SPOILERS:

Did you watch the movie from the beginning? Part of the story unfolds in a series of flashbacks. When the story begins, though we don't know it yet, Mia is the gun's owner. The first time Martin ever learns of the gun is when he finds it in Mia's purse in the restaurant (which we don't find out until a flashback much later in the movie). He sneaks it out of her purse and brings it home because he's afraid she's in some kind of trouble. He puts the gun away in a drawer, which, again, we don't see till much later in the movie. It's after that that he mistakes Penny for an intruder and takes Mia's gun out of the drawer and shoots her.

The viewer is supposed to assume that Penny was killed in the parking lot by the mugger and that Martin is so obsessed with finding her killer that he asks the police to let him have the gun so he can trace its origins.

The various gun owners we learn about are all people who owned it in the past who Martin is able to track down. At the end we find out it wasn't Penny's killer he was searching for, but actually the location of where the gun was most recently purchased, by his runaway granddaughter Mia, in Las Vegas. That's how he was able to find her to tell her about her mother's death.


reply

Thanks for the explanations. I was really interested in this movie and got lost during the ending. This really clarifies it.

"Wait a minute. You know that scum? He licked my window!" --Amanda (Diagnosis Murder)

reply

That's how I understood it as well. However, this still doesn't really make sense to me...

Mia runs away from home, ends up in Las Vegas, buys the gun, then goes all the way back to Vermont on the off chance that she can get a few bucks from her grandfather, then goes back to whatever she was doing in Las Vegas, on the complete other end of the country? Is that correct? Seems to be a lot of effort (and expense) to go to for $100, and remember she seemed even like she was a bit surprised to get that much from him.

Also, didn't really understand her statement at the end. Something to the effect of, "You wrote all those letters for me, didn't you?" He wrote those posthumous letters to Penny for Mia? I don't get that.

reply