Did she have an affair?


Is it safe to assume that Charlotte did sleep with her co-star after repeatedly denying so to her husband?
I am reminded of her husband Yvan's comments "You know something? You're a great actress" after being told again that she did not sleep with her co-star.
Having been a while since I have seen the film I cannot remember the timeline however if one assumes that Charlotte did have an affair, could it also be possible that the father of her child is infact her co-star and not Yvan?

reply

Yes, the affair is conveyed by the scene where Charlotte walks out her costar's hotel room. A scene was deleted which made it more obvious.

I don't think the father of her child could her costar. She finds out about her pregnancy the day she and Yvan see Yvan's sister in the hospital with her new baby. I got the feeling the sister was about 6 months pregnant when Charlotte's affair would have begun. Because Charlotte would not find out till a few months later, only Yvan could be the father. However, I do not know this for sure, only guessing.

reply

Yeah, it seemed pretty clear to me that they had an affair.

Didn't think much of the movie. Particularly in the second half as Attal's character becomes increasingly irritating (I don't think the desired effect of the reveal of the affair was to inspire the viewer to say aloud "good for her!" as I actually did). Gainsbourg is a charmer, though, and kept me with it to the end...

reply

Yes. She is seen leaving him in his hotel room bedchamber shortly after dawn. In the interview with the director/star that is included on the DVD, Attal says that he filmed a funny scene in which Charlotte and the Stamp character have sex in his trailer as he recites Sharkespeare. Attal says he did not include the scene in the final version because Charlotte would have appeared less sympathetic had she been portrayed as having sex with him at first one location (trailer) and then another (hotel). I liked this movie quite a lot but I didn't like her character, who was not a sympathetic character. (Charlotte Gainsbourg, however, is a terrific actress.)

reply

Attal says that he filmed a funny scene in which Charlotte and the Stamp character have sex in his trailer as he recites Sharkespeare.


LOL Did they include this on the DVD? I noticed they had a deleted scene selection but the first scene was really boring so I didn't watch any others.

reply

He mentions the scene but he doesn't include on the DVD. The deleted scenes include several takes of a scene where the Stamp character's assistant is sitting on a lawn chair outside his trailer while it bounces up and down.

reply

Apparent to everyone else but her husband- of course she did!
This is where this film lost me. Too pat an ending & resolution.
Moreover, the T. Stamp character & their affair is never fully
explored. Their "breakup" is trite, & simple. Its a good thing
they ommitted the affair from the US release. She would come across
as a lying, cheating, skank- & he as a pitiful buffoon!

reply

Lots of people have affairs when they are away travelling and alone and lonely, I should know. Does it matter, is it worth throwing a relationship away? If she returns to her husband and wants to make it work, saying without saying that she didn't mean it, it is up to her husband to realise that one mistake should not destroy the happiness they have shared in the past, and the happiness to come.

This is what she did when she grabbed him and kissed him and this is what he did when he forgave her for it.

reply

if she truly loved him though then she wouldn't have had the affair.
marilyn
xxxxxx

reply

Replying many years after the original post...but Charlotte was on Letterman
tonight as a musical performer. Who knew.
I liked the film for the most part but the affair did indeed make her less sympathetic. The jealous husband was already annoying, but at least turned down his chance at an affair. The affair simply cemented the fact that the husband was right and I ended up not liking anyone. Pretty much wrecked the movie for me.

reply

Charlotte appeared at at least two venues in New York City in support of her recently released album in Jan./Feb., 2010, but alas, I was unable to attend her performances and, unfortunately, I missed her appearance on Letterman.

As others pointed out, she had an affair with Terence Stamp's charater. At one point in the film, the Yvan husband-character in the film says that woman get a goofy look on their face when a man recites poetry, implying they can be seduced by that recitation (or someone says that, anyway). The next scene shows the Charlotte actress-character with just such a goofy look on her face as the Terence Stamp actor-character recites Shakespeare sonnets while a little tipsy from drinking beer, and while wearing the airline pilot cap his character wears in the movie-within-a-movie.

We are led to believe that this act, combined with Charlotte's loneliness, and the fights she's been having with her husband, mostly by long-distance, leads her to have sex with Stamp's character.

This is not a very good scene. The goofy look is not funny or attractive. It is just goofy, and makes the Charlotte-character look stupid. And Stamp's recitation of Shakespeare makes his character just look like an alcoholic, past-his-prime, fading matinee-idol-type actor on his way to being really drunk.

Atai, in the director's narration, says he included the scene because he likes the way British actors recite Shakesepeare, and in the deleted scene, which is only described, but not shown in the DVD special features, Atai says it was hilarious to hear Stamp reciting Shakespeare as he makes love to Charlotte, going faster and faster until he is reciting Shapespeare like a "madman."

But unless Charlotte was equally drunk, which is not made clear, this would only make her look even less sympathetic in my opinion.

reply

It would be really tough to forgive an affair, for me personally. That is about as intimate as you can get and to have your wife invite a different man into her bed (and all that goes along with that) just shows complete disrespect for her husband. Alone and lonely may make it easier to be tempted but you also make a choice to put yourself in a situation to make that temptation reality ... and that choice shows complete disrespect for your spouse ... who is likely also alone and lonely if you are away travelling ... while your getting your toes curled. It would be really tough to forgive and one thing is for sure, your relationship will never be the same.

reply

Yes, she did sleep with Stamp. Commentary track specifically states so, but it is also obvious when she slinks out of the hotel room after spending the night with him.

reply