Mental Disorder


Never has a character on screen as ''Molly'' seemed more like the classic definition of a borderline personality disorder. I know the movie is supposed to be light hearted but really it's not. She even tries to suicide off the bridge in one scene. Also where is this woman supposed to end up realistically in the future? are we really supposed to buy her as ''changed'' at the end and off to start a career. Bull.

It's actually one of the saddest films I have ever seen. I feel like Murphy's heart bleed over into the role ever so slightly exposing some possible mental instability as well. All very sad.

reply

The movie’s a comedy/drama (dramedy) that tries to be amusing while addressing weighty issues that most viewers can relate to one way or another. It also attempts to provide the answers for genuine healing and deliverance in its mere 92 minutes and, in my opinion, was successful. Let me explain…

The film sets up two broken people who are off mentally/spiritually, which – in their cases – is due to grief and the opposite ways they handle it: Molly refuses to grow up and is stuck in a flighty, messy rut spinning around in circles while Ray turns to hypochondria and stifles her emotions under the pretense of mean-spirited stoicism and neat-freak orderliness.

Molly’s failed suicide attempt is a stab at black humor, but also shows that she doesn’t know how to escape her dilemma and therefore cannot, by herself. Meanwhile Ray’s condition illustrates that “meds” (the favorite non-answer of psychiatrists) can, at best, help a person cope with their ill condition, but drugs cannot actually heal or deliver people. In fact, they usually have negative side-effects, mentally and physically.

The ‘answer’ the film provides for genuine restoration/success is twofold: (1.) finding and taking advantage of a “golden connection” and (2.) discovering and cultivating one’s special talent, whatever that might be.

(continued)

reply

Concerning the first, Molly needed someone like Ray to frankly tell her the truth (to grow up and other gems, like her quote of Mikhail Baryshnikov), but Molly also required her for other reasons (e.g. to receive and appreciate her attention/natural skills/love, which was rejected by Neal in the first act).

Ray, on the other hand, desperately needed Molly to be a mother figure and help her escape her impassive prison. The first thing Molly naturally tries to teach Ray is free-spiritedness and fun. Molly’s later advice for Ray to finally break down and talk to her comatose father – on the grounds that it would improve his condition – was not wrong, although Ray took it that way after he suddenly passes away. The only reason her father was lingering on this plane in his comatose state was because he subconsciously wanted to “talk” with his daughter and make sure she was okay before passing on.

Regarding the second, Molly discovers that her natural knack is fashion design and inspiration (not to mention her strong social gifting), which she wisely decides to cultivate thru formal schooling. Ray conversely realizes the folly of rigid stoicism while learning she is gifted as a dancer/performer.

Murphy’s premature death (from cardiac arrest due to accidental overdose of a mixture of over-the-counter & prescription drugs) was sad and tragic, but the only link it had to this movie is that Brittany inadvertently failed to take the film’s wise counsel.

reply

Brittany did not die of an overdose. It was a combination of things. But there was no lethal dose of drugs in her system. The Coroner described it this way, "The primary cause of Murphy's death was pneumonia, with secondary factors of iron-deficiency anemia and multiple drug intoxication". Yes, the over the counter drugs contributed but they were not the main cause of her death. I have 2 cousins who died of overdoses so I am not trying to sugar coat anything.

reply

Thanks for the update and clarification. I was going by the data that had been made public at the time.

reply

This movie is very, very sad. It has a dark cloud hanging over it for many reasons. The main character is mentally ill and the suicide attempt was quite disturbing for a movie marketed as a comedy. I know the film tried to even make light of he jumping off the bridge as it was too low of a jump to kill her but she still attempted.. and if it was a much higher bridge then...

Then you have the aspect of her parents dying in a plane crash as a child. A man running off with her money and leaving her with nothing. The little girl she becomes a nanny to who's father's is in a Persistent vegetative state in a home care setting who dies in the film and who has a mother who doesn't care about her. Add in Britney Murphy's premature death several years later in real life and it seals the film's fate as being a tragic drama and not a comedy.

This film is tragic. They try to add in some happy moments but it's ineffective.

reply