Was this a movie on this show?

When I was a kid, I remember watching a movie that took place in the 1800s (I think). Some young adults were playing Blind Man's Bluff in the forest. The blindfolded girl, while trying to tag her friends, walks into a cave where something dangerouns is lurking. Actually, I don't remember if it was a girl or a guy. That is all I remember but I recall being very spooked by this scene. Does anyone know the name of this movie?