MovieChat Forums > Joe Dirt (2001) Discussion > 5.2 rating? should be higher i think

5.2 rating? should be higher i think


i am usually a pretty good judge of movies and find it hard to believe this movie got such a low rating. almost everyone i talk to about this movie really likes it. sure it's no citizen kane but i think it delivers very well on what this movie is intended to be: light, entertaining and very funny! also having a couple hot chicks like jamie pressly and britney daniel helps. i like the story too. i would rate this movie a 7.5 to 8.......what about you?

reply

I say it should be higher. I love this movie.

reply

Yea this movie is hilarious, but comedies tend to have a lower rating than we'd hope because everyone has a different idea of what is funny. So one person will give it a 10 and the next might not have really got the humor so they gave it a 1.

reply

Definitely better than most comedies and deserves to be higher than a 6.

http://www.break.com/index/most-insightful-interview-ever.html

reply

should be at least 6.5

reply

[deleted]

i could see this making a cult classic along with grandma's boy

reply

love this movie. imo very underrated

reply

I'm pretty sure this movie should have won the oscar.

reply

i agree, joe dirt is so *beep* funny

reply

Totally inappropriate rating, this movie deserves at least 6.5-7.0 or higher. And Joe wasn't really THAT much of an idiot, he's an insanely honest and sincere, heartwarming character.

He doesn't have an obsession with money, power, fame... He just wants to find his parents. That itself tells a lot about him.

reply

Sure it's not a "great" movie but it's one I really don't get tired of. I will watch it over and over if I could. Probably a 7-7.5

reply

I love this movie! I never liked David Spade before and I dont even remember how or when I first saw the movie but I cant watch it enough. It was just a totally different kind of comedy that I thought was perfect. It is full of great old music and movie stars. Everyone I talk to about it has never seen or even heard of it. You can't help but like the "Joe Dirt" character and root for him. Totally underrated in my book. Ever a chance for a sequal?

We are the People, Our Parents Warned Us About

reply

Good stupid comedy, it did it's job. 7 out of 10 for me. Comedy's are a hit and miss because I think they really depend on taste. If you don't appreciate the type of humor in this movie then yeah you won't like it.

reply

Didn't really like David Spade till I saw this. I kept putting the movie off thinking it was going to be terrible. I was plesently suprised to see it was good. It's 7 good.

reply

JOE DIRT
JOE DIRT
JOE DIRT
JOE DIRT
JOE DIRT

I have given it 9. 10 I save for Shawshank lol

reply

I rated it 7/10.

"F-ckabees"

reply

7.5

reply

I TOTALLY agree! i was shocked to see the rating so low. It's hysterical with a good plot. Definitely higher than a 5.2

reply

I agree .. the rating of 5,2 is way off.. At least 7.5.

"That gentleman has placed a deposit on this meat.. No.. a monetary deposit hahaha!"

reply

Totally under-rated...

I believe it should be 8 to 8.5. Not that many movies out there can be funny and sentimental and bitter-sweet all at the same time, and endears the anti-hero lead to us without trying.

Love it!!

reply

Totally under-rated...

I believe it should be 8 to 8.5. Not that many movies out there can be funny and sentimental and bitter-sweet all at the same time, and endears the anti-hero lead to us without trying.

Love it!!


^This, precisely.

I just caught finished watching it on Comedy Central an hour ago, must be my 3rd viewing. It's just such a well-rounded comedy, not one-dimensional like a lot of others that get higher ratings on here. I guess it just had the misfortune of getting rated by a lot of snobby, wannabe film critics.

reply

I agree I think it is a great COMEDY. A classic one of my all-time favs. Deserves a 8-9 it is one of those movies that if you are channel searching and find it you watch it i.e. Old School, SuperTroopers, Waynes World, Spaceballs

reply

I don't like comedies; especially sophomoric, campy ones like Joe Dirt. I gave it an 8 though. Solid. I laugh every time I watch it. It is one of the movies that my spouse and I both enjoy re-watching.

It is an absurd movie in all the right ways.

---with only minutes to react we've somehow been killed by a stick insect -- Londinieres

reply