MovieChat Forums > XX/XY (2003) Discussion > Kathleen Robertson Kate Beckinsale

Kathleen Robertson Kate Beckinsale

posted 18 years ago by kpickette
13 replies | jump to latest

Anyone else think they look a LOT alike? At first I thought she was Kate Beckinsale.

[–] Phoenix1915 18 years ago

i agree. i didn't think it was kate, but they look a lot alike.

{I love Mr. Darcy}

No way...Maya Stang is beautiful and cherub like...While Kate Beckinsale reminds me of a stuck up cheerleader who has no emotional depth as an actor...She also has a strange face...So, no I don't think that they look alike. I wish there was more written about what Stang is doing now...She is mesmorizing.

"I have always love you, I am in love with you, and I will love you for the rest of my life."

[–] emineminy 18 years ago

No way...Maya Stang is beautiful and cherub like...While Kate Beckinsale reminds me of a stuck up cheerleader who has no emotional depth as an actor...She also has a strange face...So, no I don't think that they look alike.

I think Kate Beckinsale is beautiful, but the OP wasn't comparing her to Maya. She was comparing her to Kathleen Robertson, another very beautiful woman. I agree that they do look very much alike!

[–] stimpy35 18 years ago

Maya Stang??? The post refers to Kathleen Robertson looking like Kate Beckinsale, to which I must agree.

[–] Newlife36 18 years ago

Maybe they look alike in the face, but Kate is waaaaaaay too freaking skinny and, well, flat as a board, while Kathleen has some very nice, womanly curves. I'll take the latter any day!

My 2 cents,
Dave

[–] summerlee340 18 years ago

that's funny - I thought that to myself. I saw the movie for the second time this morning.

excellent comparison.

[–] dumpstar_drummer 18 years ago

I spent the whole movie thinking it WAS Kate Beckinsdale and wondering why she was in this less-than-awesome indie. But duh! It wasn't! It was Claire from 90210!

[–] kpickette 18 years ago

Aha, I wasn't the only one! Whoa, it didn't hit me that she was Claire either, good catch.

[–] hanrahanpm 17 years ago

Surely you all mean Cate Blanchett. There is very little resemblance between Kate Beckinsale and anyone in this movie.

[–] lasraik 17 years ago

[–] jks4usc 13 years ago

Yes, at first, I thought it was Kate Beckinsale! I checked IMDB to be sure even before the movie was over. Sure, not in total, but their faces sure are a strong look-alike.

[–] Exa84 11 years ago

Oh dear. Some of you seem to have a very poor eye for detail. No resemblance.

[–] StevieWunda 9 years ago

Yes they look alike and were born less than 3 weeks apart.