Hugh Jackman takes a total stereotype of a character and gives it soul

I think I've seen dozens of romantic comedies in which a lothario is portrayed as finally falling in love, but the character of Eddie really gives it heart and dimension. The big giveaway is the scene in the yoga studio when he sees "Becca"--that's got to be one of the most tragically romantic moments ever to occur in a light comedy. It's very effective how slowly and sensitively his romantic history is revealed, with skilled writing and skilled acting, whereas Ashley Judd's story is just put out there in a crude postfeminist cartoon characterization.

Although Ashley Judd is the more obvious main character, the slow revelation of Eddie's heartbreak ultimately becomes the most interesting and emotionally gripping thread in the story. His part in their dialogue the night before he sleeps "with her in his arms without copping a feel--well, maybe one" is also brilliant.

You--lighten up. You--big trouble. You--get in the car.