Alfredo's tat


Anybody hear anything about this? Was it supposed to be ambiguous? I wasn't sure what the "S" was supposed to mean; perhaps I missed something. I took it to be something that Alfredo had wanted for a long time (any kid whose dad is a tattoo artist would no doubt beg for one), and his dad at that moment decided that he wanted to do something for his son that would be (for lack of a better phrase) a bonding experience, something to mark him as...belonging.

That seemed to be a major theme--the contrast of one boy, who doesn't belong at home or outside of home; he isn't even seen as a real son, much less a beloved son, to his father; the other is accepted for who he is and is expected to obey his parents only because they love him.

Any ideas?

reply

No really helpful ideas other than it (the "S") being symbolic for 'Scarring'--since, according to the director, Archero Manas, the movie is NOT just about child abuse, but he said it's the parallelism, that is, the two different ways pain and scarring are inflicted. He said that the father who is a tattoo artist gives his young son an artistic tattoo which is indicative of pain and scarring with a needle, while the abusive father inflicts pain and scarring through the violence delivered with a fist, an elbow, a swift-kicking shoe toe, and/or a heel stomp. Perhaps we're searching too deeply, psychologically, and overlooking the more simple symbolism?

This magnificent film so perfectly explores the many troubling thoughts parents must experience and even sweat blood over, while simply trying to steer their children down a road straighter than their own path was; trying to guide rather than direct, help somewhat avoid rather than totally prevent their child's 'painful' opportunities in an attempt to help them to learn about the tough parts of living, without damaging their fragile psyche in the process. I do -- and did -- experience these things with my two boys -- and I was so thankful that they were boys and not girls, the latter having far more avenues into possible 'bad experiences' than most boys would. But, it's never easy, unless you overprotect them, which I believe is even far worse, since they end up knowing nothing about finding their own way through Life's trials and tribulations. God help us all.
~~
There are no ordinary moments; there's never nothing going on

reply

I haven't watched the interview with Achero MaƱas, but did he use the word 'scarring' in English?? The translation for 'scarring' in Spanish does not start with an 's', so I don't know if that would be the word the 's' stands up for in the tattoo.

reply

The tattoo is a picture of the sun; S stands for 'sol' (or Sun in Spanish)

reply