MovieChat Forums > Valentine (2001) Discussion > Where the hell did the rose and the cham...

Where the hell did the rose and the champagne come from?


Paige is sitting in the hot tub, hears the door close, looks away from 2 seconds, then all of a sudden there is a rose and a bottle of champagne there.

Michael Scott: What is a Pap smear? Or is it shmear?

reply

to make things right

in the end of the film we see page grab the champange bottle and a glas and goes to the hot tub and then chill after a while the killer shows up behind her and drops the rose behind her and then he walks out.

reply

[deleted]

Unsure what version you watched, but the one they showed on TV today didn't have the bottle popping up out of nowhere. Paige was in the hot tub and the glass and bottle were sitting there the entire time. The killer came in with the rose.

"Knowledge is not power. The application of knowledge is power."

reply

What I noticed is this:

You see the door open behind Paige. She turns around. The shot changes, and in the background you can already see the rose. There's no way he could've moved that quickly without her seeing it. It just appears.

I've got knives in my eyes, I'm going home sick.

reply

The question is, where the hell was he hiding the coat, the mask, the rose, the knife, etc. I mean, does this guy walk around with a rose in a flask (considering it didn't look battered) stuck in his pants or something!?

reply