MovieChat Forums > Bully (2001) Discussion > This or Alpha Dog...

This or Alpha Dog...




"Vive la mort, vive la guerre, vive le sacre mercenaire."

reply

Interesting contrast. Both about a teen being assassinated by a group of conspirators. Both based on true stories.

A bit apples and oranges since one was an *beep* being killed and the other an innocent.

Solid core of actors in each. I rate both movies an 8 on imdb.

Bully is more bleak, visceral and has a more realistic vibe. It has the Larry Clark scuz on it. Alpha Dog is more tragic, emotional, and is more sleek.

The murder scenes do exemplify these differences too. In Bully, the inexperienced killers meet chaos. They don't have the experience to quickly stab him to death. The victim has an "Et tu, Brute?" moment. Then a nasty finish. Bleak, visceral and believable.

In Alpha Dog there is reluctant trust and betrayal between the victim and the captors who he mostly trusted, and most of whom wouldn't have gone through with it alone. It is a more emotional execution. the movie was like a coming of age movie with a tragic ending.

I am leaning Alpha Dog by a hair. I remember a decent amount of drag in Bully. I thought there was a deeper bench of great acting in Alpha Dog.

reply

Bully, but I like both.

reply

I like the rawness of Bully.The story of Alpha Dog is sadder to me, but Bully is the better movie and the people involved in the real thing are interesting.

If you treat a girl like a dog, she's going to piss on you

reply

The book Bully is great. So is My Stolen Son by Nicks real mom


Ich bin hier, um die Werke des. Teufels zu tu. Cast a spell. Kill me Ill kill you.-KUZA

reply

I liked both, but i choose Bully

Prostitute: What the *beep* are you doing?
Johnny: I'm gonna kill a bunch of people.

reply

Bully is easier to follow & never a dull moment, Alpha Dog gets boring & confusing in spots.
Bully!

___________________
he left u NAKED in a DITCH!

reply

Alpha Dog for sure as it's one of my favorites... Only seen Bully once so I don't know wether or not it holds up to multiple views but I think it does and I liked it alot

I'm gonna refuse you an offer you can't make

reply

That's a tough question. Alpha Dog is such a great movie. But if I had to honestly choose which one is better...I'd say Bully is a better film. But hey, that's just me.

reply

The murder scene in alpha dog made me cry, the one in bully gave me chills!

reply