Italian Soldiers


If all the italian soldiers are like they have shown in the movie lets conquer italy!!!

http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=24795200
take a look:)

reply

From your name I would assume you are of Arab descent. ( Turkish, maybe? ) If you are, you, yourself should know, that movies never show what really happened and how it happened. Movies always oversimplify actual events. Movies always project prejudice. Movies always contain a great deal of fiction and assumption.

reply

I already know that italian soldiers are not like the movie show them they are. I just wanted to state how unrealistic is the movie

http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=24795200
take a look:)

reply

[deleted]

Italy was in poor shape to fight industrialized wars given that they had little infrastructure to support it. Along with it came the late unification in the 19th century. While germany unified even later most German states were highly educated and industrialized and with more than 66% territory, population and economy Prussia was the dominant power behind it.

This is the reason Italy performed poorly in WW1 and got massacred any time they faced another major European power. Even the operation against Greece overstretched their capabilities. The disarmament by German Wehrmacht units was pursued by germany precisely because the Italian troops were at this point in time so vulnerable, they didn't want to wait for them to make up their minds and decide to kill Germans.

Bottomline is that a ww2 movie however in-/accurate portrays how the Italians performed in WW2 ( which might have been brave but primarily out of their league ), not how Italy is today which is pretty much up there in standard with any NATO country.

reply

[deleted]

Many Italians didn't want to be involved with World War II in the first place - they were forced into it by the dictator Mussolini. Many of them were against it and helped the Allies secretly.

reply

[deleted]

Also many Italian soldiers were I welcomed home or even killed by those who felt that Italian had anything to do or believe w Hitler and superior race.

reply

A lot of negative propaganda about Italy, but they won in ww1.
And were praised in ww2.
The Bersaglieri beat the Americans at Kasserine pass, and were praised by Rommel.
The Folgore (paratroopers) fought to the last man in the desert war and were praisesd by Churchill.
The Alpini were praised by Stalin in Russia after they held their flank allowing the Germans and Romanians to retreat.

Eat the Neocons.

reply