Endings and Relationships


It seems that on a few threads here as well as for the '93 version of Secret Garden that a lot of people are confused about the various relationships and endings between the book and the movies. They are all a little different. Here they are accurately:

The Book ...... Mary's father and Colin's mother are brother and sister. Their mother's weren't related by blood. This does still make them cousins but at that time and place in society it wasn't as frowned upon as it is now. The book ends with the servants watching Colin, Mr. Craven, Dickon and Mary coming down the hill from the garden and amazed at the sight of Colin walking. Nothing is said of what happens in the future or who Mary ends up with (if it's either).

The 1987 film ...... Mary and Colin aren't related at all. Mary's family was friends of Colin's (it was either by grandfathers or fathers). At the end it shows Mary coming home from being a nurse in the war. She sees Colin, in army uniform, and they embrace and it's clear that they are together. They do speak of Dickon, and it's mentioned he died in the war but in a forest among the trees and animals.

The 1993 film ...... Mary and Colin's mothers were twin sisters (identical I believe). So they are still cousins. But the ending is similar to that of the book although it hints that Dickon does not end up with Mary. It shows him riding off on his horse while Mary, Colin, and Mr. Craven dance together. The last scene is of a girl (hinted at being Mary although she is a little older) walking out of the garden, the door wide open. She says something along the lines of, "The garden is always open now." It doesn't show anything about where they end up in the future though.

I hope this helps out a little.

reply

yeah this is really confusiong but i understand where yo have come from... in bacvk to the secret garden mary and colin are married and if this is a sequel!!! it means she married her cousin...

reply

yeah you are totally right. so many people are confused to what is going on. i personally like the original movie, i have yet to read the book but i know that you are probably the only person who knows what is going on.

reply

Finally a useful thread!

Thank you for clearing things out for us.

I don't understand why people make such a fuss about Mary and Colin getting married in The Secret Garden II. I believe it was something normal during that time and even now it's not like it's a crime.

reply

But the ending is similar to that of the book although it hints that Dickon does not end up with Mary. It shows him riding off on his horse while Mary, Colin, and Mr. Craven dance together. The last scene is of a girl (hinted at being Mary although she is a little older) walking out of the garden


The weird thing was I took this as a definte implication that Mary, Colin, and Mr. Craven were a "family" upon his return (Father, brother, and sister). Which is why Dickon seperated, as he wasn't a part of that central family unit that was developing. Which is why I still didn't see, despite Colin's crush, any possibility of a Colin-Mary romantic future mostly because I saw them now really growing up in a brother/sister situation. But maybe I suffer from my heart belonging to the 93' version of the garden story and my fantasy of Dickon and Mary having a romantic future.


Rhonda Weasley

reply

Then of course we cannot forget the broadway musical version, in which it is quite clear that Mary and Dickon fall in love

reply

If you're talking about the 1991 Lucy Simon musical, they certainly do not. There is nothing in the book of the musical to suggest that. Not only that, but in the original cast Mary was played by 11 year-old Daisy Eagan and Dickon was played by 27 year-old John Cameron Mitchell. Not likely that they fell in love, is it?

reply

"The 1987 film ...... Mary and Colin aren't related at all. Mary's family was friends of Colin's (it was either by grandfathers or fathers). At the end it shows Mary coming home from being a nurse in the war. She sees Colin, in army uniform, and they embrace and it's clear that they are together. They do speak of Dickon, and it's mentioned he died in the war but in a forest among the trees and animals."

Back to the Secret Garden (2001) is a sequel to that movie. The 1987 Hallmark movie deliberately altered the relationship of Mary and Colin, which then allowed Colin to propose to Mary in the end sequence that was tacked onto the movie. mention was also made in this sequence that Dickon was killed in the war, thereby removing him as a potential rival to Colin. Back to the Secret Garden and the 1987 movie were both made by Hallmark and both were filmed in the same location (Highclere Castle), both movies used a similar 'secret garden' set. The 1993 movie version reinstated Mary and Colin as cousins, and part of the same 'family.' In the 1993 movie (and the original book) it is made clear that Dickon was a working class boy and as such he would never have been tolerated as a possible suitor for a girl of Mary's class.

reply

How much do you suppose it helped that the adult Colin in the 1987 version was played by Colin Firth?



www.freerice.com

reply

[deleted]