But he's gay


I know he's an alien, but why would the everso camp James Dreyfuss be cast in a straight role and then continue to play it camp?

I think Gimme Gimme Gimme was his finest hour (I'm quite a big fan). But when you get to the top, there's only one way to go.

Bad luck James. I just hope you're earning a lot from it, cos I can't think this is going to further your career.

reply

Ever consider it is just a tv show and the point of an actor is to portray people that have a differant personality than themselves

reply

Ever consider an actor carries the same character in his every role because he's comfortable acting that way.

reply

"I know he's an alien, but why would the everso camp James Dreyfuss be cast in a straight role and then continue to play it camp?"



Well he wasn't gay in "thin blue line" either.

reply

i agree, he played it way too camp for the role. he seems to play a lot of the same characters and this didn't translate well in this context


reply

I could've lived with them parachuting in a fully different personality for George/TM as he's an alien anyway. I mean he'd even had a rather lax attitude towards loving his human wife Janet over some of the first five series (due to having a platoon of writers I'd wager) so they could have let the spousal thing drop and just have the replacement actor carry on as a lodger. What went beyond the pale was having the camp (downright girly) James Dreyfus version of George/TM persist in wanting Janet to love him presumably in the sexual sense.

That was a deal breaker for me, even after casually watching the first five series of possibly one of the most inconsistent and implausible family sitcoms I ever bothered to follow. If they had possibly let George Monday morph into whatever James Dreyfus felt comfortable doing, it may have been okay - at least not so sad.

All the cat essence nonsense and pining for Janet to let him back into her bed was pure rubbish.

Eeek!!! I'm getting dressed.

reply