Realistic?


While the performances are strong, isn't the script a bit dated? Do bisexuals (or gays who marry to please their parents) really kill themselves in 1999 (the date on the film)?

The plot line lacks credibility--unless Spain is not on the same social track as the U.S.

reply

Are you sure you watched the end of this movie grtou? Alberto did not kill himself but got into a deadly crash on his motorcycle after falling apart in front of his male lover. How did you get he killed himself? Simply because he didn't stop at the corner before proceeding on the murdercycle?

reply

It seems he did choose to kill himself. Since the accident happens off camera, and we last see him trying to face his personal situation but not seeming to find happiness in either scenario(staying with his wife or leaving her for his gay lover ) it stands to reason that he himself causes said accident in order to escape having to deal with the outcome of facing up to his dual life. I agree, that it would have been nice to see him find some sort of middle ground, but real life(unlike in televisionland) does not always have a happy or desirable conclusion.

I agree that the opening is wonderful, the sex scenes are realistic and graphic-with two decidedly straight actors-and the story seems well done, though I too had mixed feelings about the ending. This film came up in discussion while comparing the recent Brokeback Mountain to other gay themed films involving essentially a bi-focused storyline. Frankly I thought Segunda Piel was a much better movie and proof once again that the spanish(and europeans) have a much more effective grasp of sexuality in their cinema than the general american cinema does-though there are certainly exceptions, Greg Araki's recent Mysterious Skin, for example.

Hopefully people will seek out this film. it is certainly worth seeing.

reply

bisexuals (or gays who marry to please their parents)




"Kiri kiri kiri kiri kiri kiri!"
-Asami Yamazaki

reply

I don't believe he killed himself. He may have been emotionally undone at that moment, but he wasn't stupid.

reply

The idiot OP...ever heared of the word 'Spoilers'?????????

reply

I was just thinking the same thing, I'm getting f'ed off with people doing this!!!!

reply

Do bisexuals (or gays who marry to please their parents)


GOD!.I can't believe this such thing still happen in my frigid country!unbelieveable,huh? that makes people see us differently and saying that we are still living in 10.000 BC 's era

ATONEMENT(2007)10/10
AMERICAN GANGSTER(2007)10/10
3:10 TO YUMA(2007)10/10

reply

[deleted]

Exactly what I say

reply

I doubt he killed himself because he was bisexual. He had inner conflict which led him to kill himself because he was unhappy, because he didn't know who he was or what he wanted.

reply