MovieChat Forums > Plata quemada (2000) Discussion > only good queer flick ever made

only good queer flick ever made


raw, rough, unapolegetic -- a gay scarface, i can't believe this movie hasn't gotten more attention-- i was floored, getting my own copy of the dvd

reply

hedwig & the angry inch

reply

And Sunday, Bloody Sunday (NOT the U2 song).

How about looking at movies with gay main characters that don't have to s**k and f**k to be gay. (John Cusak in Con Air).

reply

Ummm...exactly HOW was John Cusack gay in Con Air. LOTs of gay stuff going on in that flick...but Cusack? I don't think so...

reply

The Hanging Garden.

I'll not reiterate my defense of this flick. Just suffice it to say that if you unplug that "I must have an A-to-B-to-C" mentality then you'll love that one too.

What about the tender love story of Midnight Cowboy?

reply

Interesting choice of examples, wmjgas. There are other films that follow the same path, and even if we don't always agree on specific characters , scenes, symbols, etc., we do find common ground in wanting to avoid sentimental crap or gratuitous stereotyping. The comments of the guy who started this thread are excellent, for example.

I urge you to find a copy of "Plata Quemada" and watch it through two or three times strictly as a movie. Then, if you want, buy the book and see how Pineyro probably convinced Piglia to cut out the clinical stuff of the book and concentrate on cinematic development of the characters from beginning to end. What emerges from the darkness of a really bloody and nasty real event is a clear, compelling, and ultimately classic tragedy that keeps you guessing and hoping in a dramatic sense even as you know that the characters are doomed.

I also like another film from Latin America known in English as "Our Lady of the Assassins." I hope there is some way "Angels in America" will make it to the big screen as well.

B24

reply

word.

There was me, that is Alex & my three droogs.There was Pete,Georgie & Dim.

reply

Huh?

reply

You are only the third one in six months to post here. Funny that we haven't had any Spanish speakers. We need one to give a few hints about whether the subtitles tell everything or if there might be something we missed. I sort of read the book it was based on, but my Spanish wasn't good enought to get more than about 80% of it. The real facts were somewhat different than the movie. Movies have to tell a story from beginning to end, but the book is more like a case study of the two main guys wrapped around the robbery itself and the last couple of days before they were killed or captured (yes, captured!). Instead of "Scarface" I compared it to the book "In Cold Blood." I also got the dvd, and my favorite part (except for when Angel takes the cigarettes away from Nene) is the transition with Billie Holliday singing in the background and Nene telling how he became a criminal as she sings the song Ill Wind. It is the way you say raw and rough, and you don't have to like these guys or understand what makes them tick to appreciate the action. Not for sentimental or fainthearted viewers.

reply

but i also noticed that your post was also only made recently-- i just can't believe that these are the first posts -- what a wild film, now i will go on to my soliliquy on gay depictions in current media-- next post (i will keep it separate)

i am sorry i don't speak spanish-- but i love this movie, i am waiting for my dvd from amazon, and after i get it, i will be able to have a more in depth discussion...

reply

My first post dates from June, I think. The film was featured on the Sundance channel several times that month, then again recently. I am not obsessive, but I admit to watching it about a dozen times so far on my dvd. I can follow most of the Spanish by now, which makes it easier to concentrate on the action visuals.

You are so right about gay syereotypes in public media. My view is that more mature characters will eventually be written, and not necessarily all winding up either in some crappy sentimental ending or in some gratuitously violent death. It's all about money to fund productions, when you get right down to it. There are serious novels and plays out there, but they need backers who aren't afraid of losing mass audience. I recently reviewed "Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil" for imdb so it is fresh in my mind. The book is unstintingly honest, but Eastwood turned the movie into a sideshow of freaky gay types. So much for that.

Have you seen "Bent"? How about "Common Ground"? Or for fun without pandering, "Trick"? Some older films with serious but closeted gay subtexts are interesting, like "Cat on a Hot Tin Roof." I intend to write a critique of the 1946 film "Gilda" one of these days, suggesting that the Rita Hayworth role should have been male, as a few people have already noted. I lack only an original script to go through without the diversion of having to think of Hayworth's dynamite performance.

I could go on talking about technical aspects or the specific appeal of "Plata Quemada," but this is too confining a place to write in. The only other contributor here and I are doing it by email.

reply

[deleted]

Watched the film again last night. I aim to watch it twice a week for the next three months as a part of my learning-to-speak-Spanish endeavor. Tried to find information on the availability of the film's soundtrack CD, but no luck. What wouldn't I give to get a recording of "Vida Mia" sung in Adriana Varela's husky voice!

Glad to read sundog's views. Yes, it would be great to have a native Spanish speaker contribute here.

reply

Here is an attempt to place the link to a tango site.

http://www.todotango.com/english/seleccion/seleccion_playlist.asp?selec=0&f=06/08/03&b=31&e=40

The only Adriana Varela selection is near the end of the entries. Did you know the tango was invented as a dance for men only? That was because there were few woman in 19th-century Buenos Aires and the men needed a way to vent their passions in a less violent way than fighting. Hence the dance which consists of many threatening gestures and very little physical contact as compared to waltzes and polkas.

At least that's what I read somewhere. Maybe true, maybe not.

reply

It´s true, tango was first invented as a dance for men only.
I´m argentinian, so if you need any help with the argentinian spanish ... I´m here.

reply

Wonderful! Had to watch it twice and now want a copy of my own too! There's more passion in a single touch between these two guys than in a truckload of porn. Want to see another no-rose-coloured glasses flic? Try "Head On".

reply

cheers to you my bro. i wholeheartedly agree. the crap that comes out of our community is not only unwatchable but downright embarassing.

reply

[deleted]

It is a Harold Arlen song called "Ill Wind." Very film noir and appropriate to this flick.

reply

[deleted]

Spanish is my first language, English my second.
Haven't seen the movie but from all the good stuff I heard will sometime rent it this week.
I'll post back after and tell if anything crucial is missing the subtitles.

reply

I think it´s too soon for me to make a review of the movie. And it´s so dense ... has so much symbols and stuff ... I will do it when i feel ready!

reply

And I hope you feel ready real soon! I've read reviews of Plata Quemada everywhere I could find them and I'm eager to read yours too.

reply

-----"""raw, rough, unapolegetic -- a gay scarface, i can't believe this movie hasn't gotten more attention-- i was floored, getting my own copy of the dvd"""---

I agree totally...the only thing missing was even a LITTLE hot manly gay lovin.

reply

yeah, the movie will be today on Cinema Tv........

reply