It is a miracle


I am from Turkey. I have not seen movie but I read many books about the Gallipoli War.the book says ,while english attacked on Turks,they entered a bunch of cloud and disappeared.I have heard many interesting events about Gallipoli war.this one is really mysterious.I think that GOD help us(TURKS) at the battlefield in Gallipoli...There can't be any explanation about it ...because there are many events that you can't beleive..I am sorry my english is not enough to tell you...

reply

[deleted]

Why would God help the Turkish army? I am not saying that any of the sides in WWI were in the right but the Turkish army was more brutal than most....

Regards,
The Count

"Science without religion is lame, religion without science is blind"

reply

[deleted]

So...did the Turks commit war crime(s) or not?
Watching the movie, and reading a bit around (including the document above), it appears (and I could be wrong) that they did commit atrocities in that particular battle.
.."dispatching"..does that mean "shooting/bayoneting/clubbing to death of POWs"?
We are aware of a deep understanding between Turkey and current governments of GB, Australia and NZ, so Turks are "good guys", but, did they or did they not kill POWs ?

reply

Everyone commits war crimes to a greater or lesser degree. Prisoners are often shot (by all sides) because they're more trouble than they're worth. If you're close to a prison camp or somewhere you can unload them, that's usually what would happen, but quite often, if you're out in the middle of nowhere, you can't spend the time, supplies or manpower to take care of them.

During WWII, if an American was told to take German prisoners back behind the lines and "hurry back", he was expected to kill them.

reply

God would not help the barbaric turks.

reply

Your post troubles me on a number of levels.... Even if the god/dess was well disposed towards the Ottoman Turks, why would she help what was only one group of invaders of the land (the Gelibolu peninsula) over another.

Remember that the whole western side of the Bosporous was only fairly recently occupied by the Ottoman Empire, having been 'stolen' from the Byzantine Empire. I can't accept that the goddess mother would want to specifically help such a bloodthirsty and barbaric tribe, particularly in the light of their own savage campaign of genocide and ethnic cleansing perpetrated against the land's rightful inhabitants: the Anatolian Greeks, the Assyrians and the Armenians. Then there's the ongoing repression, murder and ethnic cleansing of the Kurds from their own ancestral tribal homeland, a campaign that continues to this day.

These ethnic minorities have lived in their respective tribal areas since well before the days of the Hittite Empire, some five or six thousand years. Considering that the Hatti, and later the Hittites (the turkic peoples) invaded Anatolia only around 2000 bce, then THEY are the invaders! Even at its biggest historical size, the Turks never ever lived west of the Bosporous until after 1453. If anything, the goddess mother would be more likely to expunge the 'evil' Ottomans from the earth forever, like what happened to the Nazis a few years later.

reply

You think God is female, your argument is invalid.

reply

I don't think god has a sex: s/he's most definitely hermaphroditic. When you're a 3' 6" green pus-oozing goblin from the planet Zorgon in the Alpha Centauri cluster, you're so ugly nobody want's to fornicate with you. S/he has to impregnate herself. Poor god!

Actually, I'm kidding. I'm god. If you don't like it, tough. Because I'm god each & every one of my posts has validity. If you disagree then I'll execute every mo-fo last one of you, just like god does.

reply