I never got Willis


being a security guard. "You like helping people" Glass tells him. Security guards don't really help people. Oh, sure, on occasion, but probably not more often than any other bystander.

Why not make him a paramedic, EMT, volunteer firefighter ... something more along those lines.

Granted, the script emphasized what a regular Joe he was, but then being a first responder, especially in a volunteer setting, isn't exactly the height of glamour, & certainly wouldn't have made him wealthy.

Writing this after having seen "Split". Have to agree, it's a move in a better direction for Shyamalan, & probably an argument in favor of permitting filmmakers that seem on an irreversible downward slide helm yet another major production.

I don't love either film. But I find it amusing that both suckered me into superhero/villain type comix genre pictures, which I normally avoid.

Still, wrt Unbreakable, I'm bothered by protagonist's line of work. I think it would have been a much stronger film if he'd been in an actual helping line of work--even if circumstances mandated he remain on the lowest rung of the professional ladder.

reply

You do remember the scene with the gun right? He could use his “power” perfectly as a security guard to spot (touch) the people with possible bad intentions.

reply

Yes, I do. So why not be a cop, or a spy, or TSA ... or something that reflects more education & career advancement. How can he even earn enough to pay for his home as a security guard?

reply

Becaus e it's meant to show him having a mundane life, being a cop or a spy precludes that.

reply

The archetypal image of the Security guard is an image of some guy covering someone innocent (more or less) with his own body. And Willis already did that before in the 'Last Boyscout'.

reply

He has to help people based on his strengths, so a paramedic is out. Second, he needed a cool caped costume and firefighters don't have that iconic look but a waterproof poncho with a hood does.

reply