MovieChat Forums > Chasing Holden (2003) Discussion > How is this not rated Higher?

How is this not rated Higher?


I thought this movie was awesome. DJ Qualls was extremely believable as the main character. I did not think he would be able to do it, since he has primarily been in comedies. But he was great. I love this movie, but Catcher in the Rye is my favorite book. So perhaps I am biased. So many crappy movies are ranked higher than this. its absurd.

reply

People either:
1. Haven't read Catcher in the Rye
2. Think its a lame rip-off of Chasing Amy
3. Think that Catcher is a terrible book about Emo kids, and is highly overrated.

I like it personally.

It also seems that under 200 people voted XD
there you go

reply

[deleted]

1. i have read the book
2. i've never gotten around to seeing chasing amy
3. i think salinger is a great author & that catcher in the rye is a wonderful book


i hate this film. it's garbage.

reply

Not having read the book or Chasing Amy or anything like that has nothing to do with people not liking this movie. It's just a terrible movie. It's a lame attempt at honoring a great book.

reply