MovieChat Forums > Le goût des autres (2000) Discussion > I hate to be such a stupid American some...

I hate to be such a stupid American sometimes but...


Did anyone else get sort of a Tarantino feel from this film? I'm not sure whether it's because Tarantino watches a lot of French films and subsequently "borrows" ideas from them, or because this French filmmaker decided to cash in on the popularity of movies like Pulp Fiction and Reservoir Dogs.

Specifically, the beginning, two guys in suits chit-chatting, not unlike Jules and Vincent in Pulp. Or when Castella is sitting at the table with all of the artists in the bar. The way the camera was rotating around the table reminded me very distinctly of the opening diner scene in Reservoir Dogs. I'm also trying to decide what this could be considered an amalgam of. Tarantino and Jean-Luc Godard? Tarantino and Woody Allen? I'm not sure. Anyone else think this while they were watching?

reply

>or because this French filmmaker decided to cash in on the popularity of movies like Pulp Fiction and Reservoir Dogs.

No, that's for sure, i mean "le gout dea autres" and "Pulp fiction"are completly different kind of movies. Besides this movie is quite typical of bacri/jaoui work,
there is also a "chit-chat" kind of dialogue in other of their movies.



reply


You know, that's something that had never occurred to me. And I think you might have a point. I think it would be very harsh to suggest that Agnes Jaoui is trying to 'cash in' on Tarantino's films. I think it is probably more of a simple homage, perhaps Tarantino is one of her favourite filmmakers or something.
Thanks for pointing something interesting out I'd not thought of before!

reply

[deleted]

yes, I agree with didiermustdie, Tarantino is one of those thieves with white glove - actually, people have noticed how he stole (well done though) techniques and whole scenes from other movies - but it was noticed when he had already been put in the "stars coliseum".
However, he knows how to entertain, and that's a plus in these days - that's no easy - XXI century just covers your basic needs.

On the other hand, Jaoui puts life on screen, the everyday, with superb naturality.
And now I shut up because I don't write very well,
thanks

reply

[deleted]

Tarantino is a fan of French New Wave. So I suspect Tarantino and Agnès Jaoui were inspired by similar films. Plus the idea of anyone borrowing ideas from Tarantino seems weird to me. I'm sure someone has. No offense to Tarantino fans, I just find instead of just using the techniques he needs for a scene, he grabs the whole package and it ends up a homage or pastiche rather than a subtle weaving of cinematic elements. His movies become more, spot the "homage" rather than "hey nice use of rapid uneven close ups to show the character's personal state of confusion".

reply

Did anyone else get a Pedro Almodovar vibe from this film? Or maybe even a little Luis Bunuel? The constant conversations, interesting dialogue, moving camera and the play-within-a-film aspect reminded me of these filmmakers. I see the Tarantino similarities, but how many movies have a camera that revolves around a table of talking people? To me it seems a pretty common technique. The dialogue is well written, perhaps this is why it seems like a Tarantino film. Though I thought this film had a lot less action than any of the films of the directors I've mentioned. Great overall, it's definitely become one of my favorites.

reply

completely agree with darkbhudda. Like the line from Vincent Chase in Entourage..."Tarantino only steals from the best". Tarantino, while very entertaining is a hack who has ripped from(as darkbhubba stated) French New Wave, Scorsese, Coppola, 70's American black explotation films etc etc. I didn't get a Tarantino vibe at all from watching this movie, nor Almodovar, but I haven't seen nor analyzed his work enough to make an intelligible conclusion. Anyway, I just wanted to point out that damn near all French films I've seen are dialogue driven. Unfortunately us Americans are used to having cleverly written dialogue either buried or ignored by car chases, blowing s**t up, violence, or undermined in films that are weird for the sake of being weird. Great film and it was nice to see that the woman who played Manie was a key factor behind the production.

reply

I definitely got some Tarantino vibes in this moviel Frank and Bruno in the beginning did remind me of Jules and Vincent and the table scene definitely reminded me of Reservoir Dogs as well.

reply

Because Quentin Tarantino movies are the only ones in the history of cinema where two people sit at a table to talk, and because foreign filmmakers can't do anything without stealing from American directors.

/sarcasm

reply