MovieChat Forums > Malèna (2001) Discussion > What was the point of the story? *spoile...

What was the point of the story? *spoilers*


A boy, infatuated with a hot woman spies on her and learns that she is ostracized by the town's jealous, hateful women because of her sex appeal. While her husband is away at war, she becomes a prostitute as a way round being starved by the resentful women who supply the town's limited food. Eventually she is publicly beaten for sleeping with their husbands, and, upon her own husband's return, the boy writes a letter explaining to him that she wanted to stay faithful, thus protecting her honor. He eventually helps her directly by picking up some dropped oranges. The end.

The boy explained in the letter that he lacked courage, his main realisation, but I don't find this at all compelling. And what was the point in all the scenes with his family? They seemed utterly superfluous.

reply

I remember, vaguely, something about the story being amen allegory for the Italian experience of the war.

reply

The boy is a metaphor for Ego (as defined by Freud). His name is Amoroso, Amore means Love in Italian, Amoroso means "the one who is in love".
Malena is Erotic drive (as defined by Freud).
Malena's husband is Aggressive drive (as defined by Freud).
The town is the psyche (as defined by Freud).

Freud theorizes that the psyche is governed by the dynamic between the Erotic drive (life instinct) and the Aggressive drive (death instinct). When the balance between the Erotic drive and the Aggressive drive is broken, the mind goes cuckoo.

When the Aggressive drive (war) takes over the psyche, the Erotic drive is perverted (Malena becomes a whore for the army), and the psyche dives into a self destructive downward spiral.
War removed Malena's husband from the town, and when news arrive that he died, the town soon banishes Malena.

Amoroso is the force that restores the connection between Erotic drive (Malena) and Aggressive drive (Malena's husband). Amoroso restores balance to the town.

reply