MovieChat Forums > Tully (2000) Discussion > The smudge on Ella's face + other peeves

The smudge on Ella's face + other peeves


I thought it was a very good film. Something you can watch on a relaxed and rainy day. I have two nitpicks/ questions/ observation about the show, though . . .

When Tully came to pick up Ella at her house, and she was outside gardening and her grandpa was on the porch--she visibly had something on her face. She stepped inside for a second saying she was going to go "freshen up"

Well, when she came back outside and hopped in the car,and she forgot the dirt or whatever that was still on her face! It was a short time later she felt it. Embarrased, she wiped it off.

It just doesn't make sense to me that it was set up so that she went into "clean up" yet still overlooked the obvious smudge on her face. I mean, I guess that was to show that even though she was trying to make a good impression--she still was absent-minded or something; but, I think it would have been better if she hadn't gone inside at all, in my opinion. I know that would have meant Tully couldn't get those awkward moments alone with grandpa; but maybe they could have had her off somewhere else, like, having to put Bessy the cow back into the stable or something like that. Or maybe done it so that the audience really didn't see the smudge until she too noticed it.

Also, I realize this movie was probably filmed with a small budget--and they did a great job---but beings that she had returned home for the summer to work for a veterinarian, and beings that Tully's brother was raising an animal for show---it would have been good side-story to have the animal get sick/injured and Ella could have helped mend it--just in time for the auction or whatever . . .

Thoughts?

reply

There was no character named Emma in the film. There WAS however, an Ella and an Essa.

reply

Okay, I meant Ella. My bad---but instead of haughtily correcting me, how about responding to the main idea of my post? Thanks.

reply

Well, after gardening the thing you usually feel the need to do is wash your hands, so she could have conceivably missed that smudge on her face, especially if it was a rush job. The scene in the car in which she surreptiously wipes off the smudge--I think--is to let us know that she cares how she appears to Tully, and/or what he thinks about her. Just my opinion.

reply

Exactly. A guess is that she could have just went in and washed her hands in the kitchen sink. Usually there isn't a mirror about it.

reply

"It just doesn't make sense to me that it was set up so that she went into "clean up" yet still overlooked the obvious smudge on her face."


It makes sense to me. My perception is that she had to wash up, but was in a hurry to get back outside to Tully, thereby missing the smudge.

reply

Yeah, and regarding your idea for Ella saving the day with her mad veterinarian skills? Mehh... That would just seem way too convenient, campy, and unneccessary.

Fun and Failure both start out the same way. --Arrested Development.

reply

I wondered about that also, but dismissed it as a very minor detail in an excellent film.

Schrodinger's cat walks into a bar, and / or doesn't.

reply