EVERYONE IS TOO SKINNY


I hated that movie. The only person they recognised as having an eating disorder was Maureen. EVERYONE in that movie was at leat 20 pounds under weight. No one had any fat on their body. It was disgusting to watch that movie. All i could think about the whole time was that they were too skinny. It's amazing they could dance at all, people who are that skinny have osteoperosis, and it's just unbeleivable that they could even dance. They were disgusting to watch. Even the girl who was 'FAT' was too skinny. All that movie does is teach people to be anorexic. It was horrible.

reply

I agree ... but I don't think Jody or Anna were too skinny.

*For who could ever learn to love a beast?*

reply

i think they were showing what its really like in the ballet world...ballerinas are not all anorexic, but there all tiny

reply

They all have to be somewhat anorexic, no one looks like that naturally, even if they are insanely skinny naturally they still don't look like that. No one really looked alive, because they hadn't eaten enough. The only person in that movie who looked slightly real was Eva, because not every bone in her body was sticking out, and she actually had color in her face.

reply

[deleted]

I know about dance. I dance at an extremely serious competitive school. I used to do ballet, i did it for 8 years. The best dancer at our school was twice the size of the people in the movie. your weight or Body Type doesn't matter as long as you can do the steps.

Over exercising is form of eating disorder. You evercise way too much and burn more calories than you eat. "you tend to use so much of your body that it burns all the fat and leaves you with toned muscle."<That is a good example of this kind of eating disorder.

It's not just that they don't look natural because they don't have fat. I know what people who are naturally skinny look like, but the majority of people in that movie aren't naturally skinny. you can tell when someone has an eating disorder they look unrealisticly skinny, and like dead. They don't have much color to their faces and have dark circles and stuff under their eyes. The majority of the dancers in Center Stage looked like that.


You say that you are fortunate enough to have a high metabolism. So basicly you are saying that people who don't have a high metabolsim( there for not as skinny) are less fortunate. That's really insulting to people who are 'less fortunate'. You are saying right there that people who are not skinny, are not as good as people who are. That's horrible. It's disgusts me.

reply

You kid, right? You can't be lifted by men if you're overweight.

I take it you've never done ballet, before, right? Quit lying, because it's obvious.

reply

You kid, right? You can't be lifted by men if you're overweight.

I take it you've never done ballet, before, right? Quit lying, because it's obvious.


OOO BURN! AH HA HA

reply

I'm not particularily a balletdancer but your comment about practically every dancer in the movie being anorexic is not only stupid but only goes to prove that you don't know much about the world of dance, let alone the ballet world.

There is a quota that certain genre's on dance have, for instance i did ballet for two years before i moved into hip hop [in hip hop i doubt you'll get far without being able to roll your hips] and i can tell you, everyone is pretty ruthless about you not only being able to dance with the certain technique but you also have to have the right body type. I am fortunate enough to have a really high metabolism because i can eat 3 servings of my mums spaghetti without having to spew it up like a bulimic person or starve myself like someone with anorexia.

My point is that i find it insulting that you think that, what the people in the movie look like isn't natural just because they don't have any 'fat'. When you dance for as long as they have and as i have, you tend to use so much of your body that it burns all the fat and leaves you with toned muscle. End of story


Amen poisonedperfect! You are my hero, that is exactly what I think. The person who started this post needs to realize that none of the girls (besides Maureen & maybe Kathleen) were too skinny. I didn't think Maureen was too skinny, I thought she was beautiful, she had a beautiful body for a ballet dancer. The reason Eva had color in her face or whatever is because she has darker skin then the other girls, and the reason why they looked 'pale' is because they were wearing make up. And I kinda think the girl who got sent home (Emily) was kinda fat to be a ballerina. But ppl like Jody, and Juliet, and the creepy lady, and anna were no where near 'too skinny'

reply

"The only person in that movie who looked slightly real was Eva, because not every bone in her body was sticking out, and she actually had color in her face."

Actually she was just as skinny as the rest of them, and she had "color in her face" because she's, umm, BLACK.

reply

Actually, I know a couple girls that eat more than most guys I know and are tinier than ballet dancers.
If you worked half as hard as any professional ballet dancer you would be that skinny, too. It's about eating healthy, drinking a lot of water, and working out until you can't move anymore, then pushing even harder. You do that everyday and I can guarantee you would be that skinny, too.

reply

that could be because she was darker by nature.

reply

How do you know they don't look like that naturally? Do you hang out with a lot of Ballerinas? Most of the ballet dancers in this movie are professionals, and they ARE that skinny. And if you must know, I thought that Eva was the skinniest one of all, because she was just that, skinny. Everyone else was small, but they were very well toned because of the physical demands that ballet has on their bodies. Eva only had color in her face because she is black.

reply

nobody was too skinny in the movie in my personal opinion. I've been doing ballet for many many years, and i suppose compared to most people you'd see on the street, i'm "anorexic".

honestly, how many professional well-known ballet dancers are there out there who are chubby?

ballet is such a work out. i eat a lot and i'm still this way.

reply

I'm a ballet dancer and have been dancing since i was 5. The dancers there were hardly too skinny, they had beautiful elegant bodies. You've mistaken "no fat" for toned muscle... it's the way you use your body when you dance, what you let go of isn't just your middle as Juliette Simone said...

reply

Yes, you're right...all the dancers were beautifully in shape. Jody, Anna, Charlie, Ethan, Eric...they were all average. Eva was VERY thin...but that's her body type (drat it...wish I looked like that) and Maureen was thin but not grossly so. The only person who looked a little less than healthy (and she was extremely toned and strong...like a rubber band) was Julie Kent, who played Kathleen. But then, Julie Kent is a professional ballet dancer and dances a bzillion hours each day. I agree, when you dance hours every day...it really doesn't matter if you eat "3 plates of spaghetti" :) you will still maintain a trim waistline and lean figure. I'm a ballet dancer as well (since age of four) and the dancers in the movie look exactly like the dancers at Houston ballet, Austin ballet, and millions of other dance companies around the world.

reply

[deleted]

Hey,

Our names are Maddie and Nicki,
I'm Nicki, a full time dancer in Australia. I recently competed at the Genee International Compeition and I'm skinny, I will admit it. But in comparison to alot of those girls at the competition I think i weighed quite a bit more. I will not go changing myself because I was very sucsessful!
And the thing is the skinny anorexic girls didn't get a place or anything, so it's a waste on them.
There is so much pressure on a dancers body, and although in the movie Emily was not fat at all I think the director was trying to emphasise the point of what a tough industry ballet really is.

Love Nicki

Hey I'm Maddie! and i agree with nicki :) :)

Toodles Maddie



reply

I'm a ballet dancer and everyone I know looks like that. It's because we dont sit on our butts all day and stuff our faces with big macs like the rest of you.

reply

LOL. I agree somewhat there, but I know people who work out ALL THE TIME and hardly ever eat fatty foods and they are still overweight. Some people just can't loose pounds while others, dancers and people on sports teams, can.Usually.

PMS-Putting up with Mens *beep*

reply

It's not about not eating fatty foods, you can eat pure fat and still loose weight. IF calorie intake is less than energy spent in a day weight goes down....if not you've got a medical condition and should get it checked out ASAP

reply

Very true. Between the ages of 10 and 12 I figure skated for 20 hours a week, and from 12 to 17 I figure skated 40 hours a week... on top of regular school hours, on top of work, on top of other sports. I was still a big girl. Muscle on some people is voluminous. I had massive legs (thighs/calves) and arms (shoulders/biceps). We are simply built differently. I was a good individual skater, but NEVER could a male partner have lifted me.

***So I've seen 4 movies/wk in theatre for a 1/4 century, call me crazy?**

reply

hey- FYI, if you want to dance with a world-class ballet company, you DO have to be thin. it's not enough just to be able to do the steps. whether you like it or not, an overweight person does NOT look as good on stage as a slim person, AND they are not as easy to partner. i'm not saying this to be rude or cruel i'm saying it because it's true. i have met several of the dancers in this movie. in person they look very beautiful and healthy and i know for a fact they DO NOT have eating disorders.

reply

'I'm a ballet dancer and everyone I know looks like that. It's because we dont sit on our butts all day and stuff our faces with big macs like the rest of you.'

that is frickin rude

reply

Yea, but so true in part.

PMS-Putting up with Mens *beep*

reply

I dance. I do modern now, but I used to do ballet, tap, modern, hip-hop, baton, cheerleading, and gymnatics. No joke. 3 of my friends kept with ballet for their company choice and dropped weight really quick...when I picked up my company choice (modern) I gained 10 pounds...almost all muscle. When you do ballet, the movement is very sleek and slow...it tones you muscle and burns like a zillion calories every time you dance. Modern is more jolty so I buitl muscle and burned fat...but my muscles didn't get sleek...they got more bulk. So, being that skinny from doing ballet is not uncommon. My 3 ballet friends are a size 0...all 3 of them. I though am a size 5. But for our muscle/fat ratio we're about he same.

reply

no...no....you just vomit your big macs;-)....hey im not knocking it...I have lost 69lbs since april spewing my food.

reply


'I'm a ballet dancer and everyone I know looks like that. It's because we dont sit on our butts all day and stuff our faces with big macs like the rest of you.'

that is frickin rude


Ha ha that is frickin hilarious I laughed out loud when I read that line earlier in the post.

reply

George Balanchine and his "ideal" baby ballerinas still have a hold on many classical dancers -- Mr. B did encourage his ballerinas to starve themselves, to work at a pale, translucent complexion and to have collagen injections into their lips -- he wanted wispy, wide-eyed, pale dancers with pouty lips and they nearly killed themselves to please him. Things are much better, but I think Balanchine's ideal is still much in evidence.

reply

are you an idiot. They are ALL actual dancers except Susan May Pratt(Maureen). Have you ever seen a REAL ballet on stage in front of you? Probably not since your bitching about this. But ALL ballet dancers are extremely skinny and "flat" because of the tremendous amount of work their bodies undergo. And with that much stress on your body you eventually stop developing. Its the same thing with gymnasts. But ballet dancers dont use as much muscle as gymnasts do. So they arent too skinny. They are perfectly healthy for their sport.

reply

It's a common misconception that ballet dancers do "slow and sleek" movement. Have you ever seen a Balanchine ballet??? Try doing one sometime and you'll see how incredibly fast you have to move, AND you have to make it look completely effortless at the same time.

reply

[deleted]

um. HELLO, they look like that because they're dancers. the fact that they are skinny is because they dance so much and they dont just sit around like alot of people. just because their muscles are toned and they're skinny doesnt make the movie awful. it makes it more realistic. im not a dancer, im a gymnast. but i have many friends who dance and they all look like the people in this movie. and i have to agree with the person that said "Eva has color in her face because she's BLACK" HELLO, of course!

reply

ballerinas are small...they're normal for ballet dancers. ballet doesn't create bulky muscle -- it makes you look skinnier because of the lengthened muscles. they would have been a lotttt skinnier if they were anorexic.

reply

Unfair: This is ridiculous. People in general flip out more when they see a skinny person than they do when they see an overweight person. And most of the time the overweight person has more health problems than the underweight person! Even though obesity is rampant, thin people are becoming more and more victimized!

reply

Unfair: This is ridiculous. People in general flip out more when they see a skinny person than they do when they see an overweight person. And most of the time the overweight person has more health problems than the underweight person! Even though obesity is rampant, thin people are becoming more and more victimized!


That is what's up! You have said a lot of true and intellegent things through out the post shadyballerina. You are not making yourself look like an idiot like the person who started this post. Really person (I'm going to call him/her "person") Ok really person a lot of people are going against you on this one, and they have very valid facts to back them up.

reply

Unfair: This is ridiculous. People in general flip out more when they see a skinny person than they do when they see an overweight person. And most of the time the overweight person has more health problems than the underweight person! Even though obesity is rampant, thin people are becoming more and more victimized!
Being overweight and underweight are equally unhealthy. However, I agree with everyone who thinks the dancers in this movie weren't underweight. They were slim but they're (nearly) pro dancers - they work to much to develope any fat, it's not as if they starve themselves to get that slim. Actually, they probably eat a lot to have the energy and strength to dance all day. As others have said, it's from all the dancing and not a lack of food that they look like that.
But ALL ballet dancers are extremely skinny and "flat"
Thin, yes, but not necessarily flat. I know a girl who has been dancing since she was 5 and is a size 30DD. Boobs are made more breat tissue so some dancers will always have big breasts no matter how hard they work out. But if you meant pro dancers then it's probably true that most of the are flat - there aren't that many companies that will accept dancers with curves (although this is slowly changing. Strong is the new thin).
Over exercising is form of eating disorder. You evercise way too much and burn more calories than you eat. "you tend to use so much of your body that it burns all the fat and leaves you with toned muscle."<That is a good example of this kind of eating disorder.
You were right about the over exercising being a form of eating disorder, but the example you gave was completley wrong. That is exercising, not over exercising. Ballet dancers are trained and so they are getting controlled exercise. And from their training they are left with "no fat and toned muscles".

reply

when obese people make up over half the population you can be certain they'll be attacking their threats.

reply