True, Ian was a prankster, but they really screwed up the dancing thing. The plot of "The Dance" was that Ian wasn't going to go to his niece's wedding because he'd have to dance with her, so Maddie agreed to teach him how to dance. That was all played straight. On its own, it was a great, heartfelt episode (hilariously narrated by Tess, who was trying to fix up Ian & Maddie), but it wasn't consistent with Ian dancing on the ledge in the "Pilot" (the clip from the opening credits) or the reveal in the subsequent episode.
Should have denoted a spoiler, but later in "Secrets and Lies," Ian ultimately shows Henry a video from the early '80s that he referred to as his deepest, darkest secret... On the tape, a mustache-less Ian, as part of the dance troupe 'The Grinning Americans,' is doing a tacky dance routine to the song "I'm So Excited." Different kind of dancing, but if he'd worked with a choreographer, it's illogical to think that he couldn't slow-dance with his niece.
reply
share