MovieChat Forums > Survival Island (2002) Discussion > If Pinata Demon Island is a worse film t...

If Pinata Demon Island is a worse film than....


Manos the hands of fate, then manos is just hard for me to imagine. I really need to pick up the mystery science theatre version and compare it to this film. I mean, Pinata is just terrible terrible terrible. For a worse film to exist is an injustice.

People who have seen both, what is the verdict?

reply

[deleted]

I would say Manos Hands of Fate is the worse of the two. Pinata Island at least had some hot babes to look at.

reply

At least Manos tried and failed, miserably but it tried. Pinata just bludgeoned me with raw stupidity until the credits started to roll. Sure, it' funny if you've got a friend with you to help share the load, but alone it's like watching a drooling retard stick a fork in a light socket over and over and over for an hour and a half.

reply

LOL!!! Your analogy is awesome. I laughed quite a lot reading it. :-)

reply

Live ta make ya laugh. I have a love-hate relationship with most modern B-movies. It's like after the 80's, b-movie makers just stopped trying and actually set out to make bad movies, which just boggles my mind.

reply

"Live ta make ya laugh. I have a love-hate relationship with most modern B-movies. It's like after the 80's, b-movie makers just stopped trying and actually set out to make bad movies, which just boggles my mind."

Wow, I just started a topic on this board along those lines. Agreed, man. Somewhere post-modernism got in the way (was it Scream?) and no one has the courage to just be genuinely bad anymore. Now all the talentless hacks have evasions for their lack of competence, and there's no one with a strong enough mix of passion, ambition, and moderate self-delusion to take the weight. Maybe Uwe Boll's our only hope?


"If you knew how I felt now, you wouldn't act so adult now." - The Replacements

reply

But...Mark Hamill needed a veeeeehicle!

That's actually a better title for this film. I can just head the MovieFone guy now...

"For 'Drooling Retard With a Fork', press ooooooone."

reply

"A drooling retard sticks a fork in a light socket over and over and over for an hour and a half" is the working title of the next Adam Sandler movie.

Sincerely, yahmez the mad.

reply

Well, I guess it did give Nicholas Brendon a couple of pennies towards his bank account since Buffy was gone. With Hollywood running out of ideas and stealing movies directly from kiddies video games lately, it really isn't a surprise that crap like this is being made. On the brighter side, I hear ABC has just decided to make a pilot about the Geico CAVEMAN guy. At least he's entertaining.

reply

Manos is worse, hands down. Of course, "Birdemic: Shock and Terror" is even worse than Manos. I have watched about 60% of the Bottom 100, "Demon Island" aka "Pinata Survival Island" is one of the better films on it. It was merely a retarded concept, executed cheaply. Quite a few of these films are retarded concept, executed ineptly, by the insane. Especially Birdemic.

Sincerely, yahmez the mad.

reply