Whaaa?

How secret can this society be if they all have skull-shaped scars on their wrists and wear skull-shaped keys around their necks and hang out in a building that has skulls all over it? Okay, they wear the watches over the scars, but do they wear the watches when they go swimming or have sex? I realize if they had all branded each other on the ass it would've seemed a bit gay, but it would've been a little easier to hide. And they wear the keys under their shirts, but won't they fall out of their shirts when they're doing keg stands?

And then there's the ending... How has anything been resolved? Caleb's dad was shot in the shoulder. He's not DEAD. Who's to say the Senator's gonna take over and Caleb's dad won't keep trying to kill Pacey? I have to stop now, b/c this movie is too stupid to analyze.