Is it a hoax?


After watching it for some time the number of utterances of "einsteinbrain" and "ahhh soo" just became too much. This must be a hoax. This guy must be an agent provacateur sending up these American rubes.

But no. It's real.

"Driving Mr Albert" confirms it on page p135 to 136 show it to be real.

I guess that makes the whole thing even weirder. I can't jsut brush it off as a hoax.

BTW, in the version that I've seen (the recorded from Swedish TV) the intial opening theme is that used on BBC's Arena. I don't know if this movie was show and distributed in the Arena series (this is the sort of thing they would show) but the tiles lack the confirming series titles with the "floating neon sign in the bottle" opening (if you;ve seen an Arena you know what I mean). Does anyone know? There is no evidence for or against this on the web.

reply

Great surreal film. William S. Burroughs makes an uncredited cameo. Maybe he was living in Kansas at the time of the filming.

reply

He was living in Lawrence, Kansas at the time of the filming, after moving there to get away from the "excesses" of life at the Bunker in New York. There are a couple of things that make me think this has to be "staged" (in a very loose sense), the fact that Burroughs happens to be watching "The Day After" at the moment when Kansas gets obliterated and secondly, the name of the television repair shop where it is shot is called "Bill's" (Bill is obviously the shortened version of William and sometimes he gets referred to as Bill Burroughs by his friends)...however the way Burroughs is dressed (in his rather fetching distressed queer-redneck combination) and the way he stands outside the shop, if you had no idea who he was, you would assume he was the "Bill" of Bill's television repair shop.

My favourite WS Burroughs cameo next to his appearance on the 1984 German classic, Decoder.

PS> of course this "staging" does make you think, what other scenes are like this? The story is of course true, but even so, there is clearly artifice involved (cue argument about realism and documentary narratives).

PPS> This is made by the BBC and the Arena music at the start really makes me think, was it shown as part of the Arena series, or commissioned and never used for some inexplicable reason?

reply

I just saw the documentary on Dutch television, where it was discussed by a dutch journalist/filmcritic. And I am sorry to say it is fake, al participants (not actors)do and say what was asked of them.
Altough some elements of the ``documentary´´ are based on facts. The autopsy was in fact performed bij dr. Thomas harvey, who removed the brain. But where the brain really is today is unknown.
When this documentary was first shown in 1994 it caused a lot of controversy.
Many critics and filmmakers raised the question how true a documentary must be?
To the viewers who loved this documentary (I am one of them)I recomend a dutch documentary called ``De Tranen Van Castro´´= The tears of Castro.
This also is a fake documentary of a man who is a member of the dutch socialist party and travels to Cuba to meet his hero, Fidel Castro. His mission is to meet the Cuban leader, but at the end he only succeeds to obtain the tears of Castro via a personal medical doctor of his. This was the graduation-film of Merlijn Passiers (1972)who graduated from the Dutch Film and Televion Academy in 1997. It won the Dutch Film award for best short documentary and best actor.

reply

I also just saw the documentary (again), and I also did some research, and I believe the documentary is real. I saw several documentarys about Einstein's brains, and the dr. Thomas Harvey in the documentary is the 'real' doctor.. as are the other persons 'acting'.
This kind of documentary is also known as 'fake-fake'; it looks fake but IS real.

reply

Hi, guys, I'm the guy you can thank for the availability of the Swedish-subtitled version. I've received some e-mails regarding the recent Dutch broadcast of the documentary, and I'm out to put out some small fires all over the net.

When I first saw Eintein's Brain, I suspected it was fake myself, but nothing I've later read about the film suggests it's not real. Like Kevin said in the original post, there's a book out called Driving Mister Albert, where a journalist tells the story about the time he drove Thomas Harvey across the US to deliver the brain to Evelyn Einstein. Throughout the book, he meets several people involved in the documentary, including Evelyn Einstein, director Kevin Hull, Dr. Zimmermann, and even Professor Sugimoto. Sugimoto even excitedly shows the author his slice of brain.

There is also an article you might want to read called "Wo ist Einsteins Denkorgan", which you'll find online if you search for the title. Here, both Harvey and Sugimoto's indentities are confirmed. It's in German, though, so you'll have to rely on automated translations if you don't read it.

If anyone can give me some info on the comments made on Dutch television, that would be awesome. I've heard many claim it's fake, but I've yet to hear anyone actually present any evidence to back it up. Most of the time, people are jsut assuming it's fake because of its outrageousness.

reply

[deleted]



Thank You, Pjalne :)

reply

Many many thanks Pjalne, for kindly sharing your rip with the world! Yours seems to be the only version available on the net (Youtube, Veehd, download as RS files) and without your contribution, I imagine only a handful of people would have ever seen it!

Though it was made by BBC films, I can find no reference to it been shown on the BBC. The 'Arena' music at the start makes me think (a previous comment also mentions this connection) it was a documentary made for the series, but for some reason never shown..though the lack of the floating bottle that always accompanies the start of an Arena documentary makes me wonder...

Also the prefix of the word "Relics", I did wonder if there was a series called "Relics" on the BBC and this documentary was made for that..but again, this is total speculation..or maybe the 'Relics' tag comes from the Swedish showing of the film? The actual documentary title seems to just be "Einstein's Brain".

It is amazing how many people just assume something is true or fake based on the most flimsy of assumptions..sometimes truth is simply stranger than fiction.

PS> Talhotblond and Catfish are two interesting "is it..isn't it" documentaries of recent years.

reply

Real or not, I just wanted to thank you for uploading it

reply