MovieChat Forums > Queer as Folk (1999) Discussion > Does anyone else think Craig Kelly would...

Does anyone else think Craig Kelly would have been better as Stuart?


I'm sorry he was way better looking than Aiden Gillan, I found it soooooooooooo laughable that Stuart was the "goodlooking" one and vince was the underdog. I'm sorry but in real life no one would be worshipping Stuart like that, they wouldn't bat an eye lid at him.

reply

No way, he would have had to been brutal as a character and Craig Kelly can never seem to do that. As for what is good looking, AG is a mega sex symbol to many so it seems to be what you make of him. AG and CK were perfect for the roles they were cast in. Looks do not make a character, character does but luckily AG has both. End of.

reply

Are you insane?! He's sweed but bland. Aidan, on the other hand, is the quintessential homme fatale - and one of the most beautiful men that have EVER walked good old Earth.

reply

No he really isnt, hes average at best

reply

They're both good looking but Aidan Gillen is far sexier! Sexiness isn't just about looks, it's about charisma and he certainly pulled that off. He's still sexy now (in my mind anyway). Craig Kelly was good in his role as the shy, good boy who follows the rules

reply

[deleted]

Well, attractiveness is subjective, so not everybody will see him in the same light.

reply

Sorry, but this is the most ridiculous post on IMDB ever.

The answer is no. To ask this question, you can't have ever watched the programme.


"But I have infinite tenderness for you. I always will. My whole life."

reply

I agree with The Icon

reply