MovieChat Forums > Addio zio Tom (1971) Discussion > WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!

WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!


Are you kidding me? Why did they re-realese this mess, and why is it not banned. I thought I was pissed after seeing Birth Of A Nation, Rosewood, Amistad, and Roots. This was far more disgusting, revolting, disheartening, shocking, etc, etc, than all of those movies combined! I have to agree with Ebert on his review on this, and that has to be a first on my part. Wow! That's all I gotta say. If I show this to some of my friends/family, they would flipped the F out. I know I did.


reply

Now that I'e calmed down. Question....




Spoilers below, sort of.




Around the 48 minutes mark, there is a funeral? Who was it and why are some people upset, but a lot more of them are drunk, cheerful, and or happy? Was this all the same scene or "cut and paste" for different events.


reply

To answer the question..I'm not sure if the funeral he is talking about is one in the English or Italian version. I know there is a funeral scene in the Italian version of Martin Luther King. The italian version and English version are quite different movies.

reply

[deleted]

Eight years later, I see no one has responded.

I don't think that was a funeral (unless it was portrayed as such in this other version), it was showing how even religion was used to condone slavery, much the same way religion was done in the civil rights era, with KKK meetings in the church, likewise showing whites sitting at the front of the church, but the slaves only allowed to stand in the back.

I just watched this program yesterday for the first time, having never heard of it, and it was truly an eye-opener. I then went to see Nate Parker's Birth of A Nation.

But back to GUT, I was blown away by its frankness and its depictions. I wondered where it was filmed and see now this was done in Haiti, as well as now it's been almost fifty years ago.

All these 'exploited men, women and children' are now elderly, and all the white people, as old as they were, have surely passed on.

I don't see it as dark humor. After the gang rape, everything that came next was just draining and difficult to become enraged over (I'm white, by the way) as it was all just how these people, the slaves, were treated and exploited over two hundred years ago. Nothing could be changed about it.

Much like Birth of A Nation, it is also apparent that many of these white attitudes and thoughts are still prevalent today. That's really what was truly shocking for me.

reply

If you didn't like those other movies about slavery, then why would you watch this? This isn't one of those movies that you pick up off the shelf at blockbuster and have no idea what it is.

reply

I did get it from blockbuster (online). I had an inkling about what it was about, but did not have a clue (I rarely read reviews beforehand) that it would be so graphic and detailed in its evilness.

reply

Maybe you should do your research next time. These are the guys that did Mondo Cane.

reply

[deleted]

I havent seen it. What's so disturbing? I get that slavery is a terrible thing but it's nothing I haven't seen in films. Where does this one cross the line?

reply

This doesn't actually cross the line in any particular way but, being the product of two sleazy exploitation makers(and i'm using the term in the most derogatory way) as jacopetti and prospero, it contains various sequences of graphic sex, violence, torture and abuse. People take it as an important and serious movie about the issue of slavery but i think it's actually just sick and repulsive trash. Mondos, and pseudo-mondos like this one are the only true "torture porn"...

reply

[deleted]

I have seen all of their other films dude. Neverming, you would not understand....

reply

In a way, this is the BEST film about slavery.

Is not a film about slavery supposed to evil, graphic, and shocking?

Every high school senior in the U.S. should be made to watch this film before graduating.
It really open up one's eyes to the wretchedness of slavery.
A VERY important film.

"Belief is the Death of Intelligence" - Robert Anton Wilson

reply

crazy italianoes,guess they should have stuck to making rocky films............GO ROCKO

reply

This movie goes perfectly with Gone with the wind.

My World: http://www.imdb.com/list/xV-oKAMa9aA/

reply

I preferred this movie over other movies about slavery. It doesn't sanitize it. Slavery wasn't pretty. Not all white folks were benevolent. Others criticize this film for being exploitative but guess what slavery was exploitative in the most cruel ways. The film uses real excerpts from historical documents and reenacts them. I've studied quite a bit about slavery in the US and most high school text books don't cover the half of it. The movie doesn't even go as far as it could. It never really went into how many people died and were murdered during the transatlantic slave trade. Over a third of the people who boarded never made it here and there were millions transported to the Americas.

reply

[deleted]

You ask "why is it not banned." We don't "ban" movies here in the United States! This is the land of liberty, free speech and all that. We even outlawed human slavery almost 150 years ago.

reply

...disgusting, revolting, disheatening, shocking...
AND
disturbing and strangely exhilarating.Loved it!

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

This movie makes BoAN look like a Saturday morning special

reply