MovieChat Forums > Mansfield Park (1999) Discussion > Movie Fanny vs. Book Fanny

Movie Fanny vs. Book Fanny


Completely and totally different. The Fanny portrayed in the movie is too much like the Mary Crawford character in the book. Fanny in the book is very placid, kind, gentle, and would never imagine saying many of the things the Fanny in the movie says.

Mary Crawford and Fanny are meant to be foils to each other, but in the movie they are very similar. I still like this movie, but honestly, in this version, there is no reason for Fanny to choose Edmond over Henry. It is not who Edmond and Henry are, but who Fanny is, that prompts her to choose Edmond in the book. In the movie, there is no clear moral propriety in Fanny's character.

reply

What can I say but that I agree with your assessment of the character. I however, did not like this movie. I didn't think the mixture of Austen-plot and the changes of characterisation and especially Fanny's actions held together well.

"Now go away before I taunt you a second time."

reply