Leelee Sobieski vs Milla Jovovich
Leelee Sobieski is definitely better than Milla Hands down.
and Peter O'Toole... hell, you can't go wrong with him no matter what.
"The Messenger" had more of a "Braveheart" feel to it which basically robbed it of what it could have been.
So now, having seen both... this one is definitely better.