MovieChat Forums > Magnolia (2000) Discussion > Couple of questions about Tom Cruise's T...

Couple of questions about Tom Cruise's T.J. Mackey character.


Hi folks, how are you? I have a couple of questions about Tom Cruise's T.J. Mackey character, for those of you who have seen and understood the film well, including his character, please allow me to proceed.

1). Why exactly did he become so mysoginistic? I mean, I can understand full well him hating and being incredibly angry at his father even at the end when he is dying for leaving his mother in a horrible state like that, but what does any of this got to do with his rather negative attitude towards women?

2). How come even though he is mysoginistic, he still wants and desires and even advocates having sex with women? How can you have sex with someone who you don't like? I mean, I know that being mysoginistic in the first place is not good but it is rather confusing how one can hate someone or even some gender and STILL want to get intimate and sexual with someone? Giving how a lot of people also find sex itself gross, how can one desire it with someone or even someone of the kind one DOESN'T have a positive opinion of?

3). In his speech defending men, do you think that if T.J. Mackey was more intelligent and honest, and NOT a mysoginist at all, he could've said something that is ACTUALLY right so as to talk about gender equality and how to properly react if women ALSO do bad things? Forget feminism and men's rights or whatever, as an intelligent human being, who is actually RIGHT in this? If good and evil were and are simple concepts, and facts exist, what is the 100% correct opinion on this NO MATTER what people think?

4). Not defending him OR his speech about "Isn't that right when they say men are sh*t?" but I was wondering, if he wanted to EXPAND on his side defending men and giving examples of women ALSO doing bad things, could he have also spoken about stuff how women also commit crime, including murder, as well as, unbelievable as it may sound, sexual abuse and rape against OTHER men, and maybe even mention films like "Thursday" (1998) by Skip Woods or anything of that sort, including the German "Ilsa" films and whatnot, and even maybe mention how real life ITSELF had a notorious figure in the shape of Elizabeth Bathory, who was a woman committing an INCREDIBLE act of murderous atrocity and if he DID go that far, do you think he would have been applauded or booed at?

5). OK, not quite a question about him, but what was the main reason his father left his mother like that when she had cancer? Was he just a spoiled and selfish bastard?

6). Do you think he EVER thought about how, given his mysoginistic side, women and men who do bad things should be punished EQUALLY, including by law, or by revenge, if the law was unable to touch them? I know he hasn't spoken about it but do you think this aspect EVER crossed his mind? I don't intend to sound too gruesome OR mysoginistic myself but I kinda wonder - since he spoke in defense of the male race and also highlighted how women ALSO do bad things in life, has a thought of that caliber EVER crossed his mind?

7). If I am kind of missing the point here with some of THOSE questions, do you think that maybe he is mysoginistic from ANOTHER side or for totally DIFFERENT reasons and maybe even not mysoginistic at all (his father WAS a man at the end and look at how much criticism he launched at him at the end and even said how much he felt sorry for his mother!) and that he probably doesn't HATE women as such, which probably explains why he still has SEXUAL desires for them as evidenced by his show but rather - he is mysoginistic in a sense that HAVING such intense sexual desires for women like that and seeing them as sex objects is in ITSELF mysoginistic as it tramples over women's primary rights, as sex is indeed a human right itself and ought to be respected, right? But am I correct on THIS side or am I trying to read a little too much into Tom Cruise's T.J. Mackey character and his mentality and points of view?

Many thanks!

The greatest trick the Devil has ever pulled was convincing the world he didn't exist!

reply

1). Why exactly did he become so mysoginistic? I mean, I can understand full well him hating and being incredibly angry at his father even at the end when he is dying for leaving his mother in a horrible state like that, but what does any of this got to do with his rather negative attitude towards women?

I once did a character bio on him. Basically his father was a misogynist too and he saw his dad treat his mom horribly, so he mistook treating women badly for showing them affection. Plus there's the poor role model idea. I also had a theory he was angry at his mom for dying when he was young so that may have contributed.

2). How come even though he is mysoginistic, he still wants and desires and even advocates having sex with women? How can you have sex with someone who you don't like? I mean, I know that being mysoginistic in the first place is not good but it is rather confusing how one can hate someone or even some gender and STILL want to get intimate and sexual with someone? Giving how a lot of people also find sex itself gross, how can one desire it with someone or even someone of the kind one DOESN'T have a positive opinion of?



Why would being a misogynist mean you don't want sex with a woman? That makes no sense. You think your sex drive goes away because you hate women??? You think your sexual preference changes??? Plus having sex with women can be revenge on them--you break their hearts. And meaningless sex can be a way to fill a void in your life.

3). In his speech defending men, do you think that if T.J. Mackey was more intelligent and honest, and NOT a mysoginist at all, he could've said something that is ACTUALLY right so as to talk about gender equality and how to properly react if women ALSO do bad things? Forget feminism and men's rights or whatever, as an intelligent human being, who is actually RIGHT in this? If good and evil were and are simple concepts, and facts exist, what is the 100% correct opinion on this NO MATTER what people think?


It's more complicated than that. There is no "100% opinion". In life there is no 100% right or 100% wrong in almost any case. Shades of grey in almost everything.

4). Not defending him OR his speech about "Isn't that right when they say men are sh*t?" but I was wondering, if he wanted to EXPAND on his side defending men and giving examples of women ALSO doing bad things, could he have also spoken about stuff how women also commit crime, including murder, as well as, unbelievable as it may sound, sexual abuse and rape against OTHER men, and maybe even mention films like "Thursday" (1998) by Skip Woods or anything of that sort, including the German "Ilsa" films and whatnot, and even maybe mention how real life ITSELF had a notorious figure in the shape of Elizabeth Bathory, who was a woman committing an INCREDIBLE act of murderous atrocity and if he DID go that far, do you think he would have been applauded or booed at?


Women commit rape and it happens a lot more than people will ever acknowledge. This has nothing to do with the Frank character but I'll bite. Rape is one of the few things that is 100% wrong. If someone commits rape it should ALWAYS be prosecuted. Same with cold blooded murder. There is no excuse for either EVER. I don't see how anyone can argue this.

5). OK, not quite a question about him, but what was the main reason his father left his mother like that when she had cancer? Was he just a spoiled and selfish bastard?


We are lead to believe that he was at the time. I suspect he was a misogynist as well. He probably was a product of his times (though that does not excuse it). He regretted it though, so he wasn't all horrible (again shades of grey)/

6). Do you think he EVER thought about how, given his mysoginistic side, women and men who do bad things should be punished EQUALLY, including by law, or by revenge, if the law was unable to touch them? I know he hasn't spoken about it but do you think this aspect EVER crossed his mind? I don't intend to sound too gruesome OR mysoginistic myself but I kinda wonder - since he spoke in defense of the male race and also highlighted how women ALSO do bad things in life, has a thought of that caliber EVER crossed his mind?


Women and men should be punished the same. However, revenge should not be considered.

7). If I am kind of missing the point here with some of THOSE questions, do you think that maybe he is mysoginistic from ANOTHER side or for totally DIFFERENT reasons and maybe even not mysoginistic at all (his father WAS a man at the end and look at how much criticism he launched at him at the end and even said how much he felt sorry for his mother!) and that he probably doesn't HATE women as such, which probably explains why he still has SEXUAL desires for them as evidenced by his show but rather - he is mysoginistic in a sense that HAVING such intense sexual desires for women like that and seeing them as sex objects is in ITSELF mysoginistic as it tramples over women's primary rights, as sex is indeed a human right itself and ought to be respected, right? But am I correct on THIS side or am I trying to read a little too much into Tom Cruise's T.J. Mackey character and his mentality and points of view?


He IS a misogynist in the same way a "I have black friends" racist is still a racist. It's complicated, but a person who says the things he does is ALWAYS a misogynist. Intent isn't the point. Sexual desires are inconsequential, they are 100% biological. I don't know why you think they have anything to do with being a misogynist. Misogynists often have MORE sex with women and in fact having more sex is a SIGN of being one in most cases.


Characters are more important than plot.

reply

"I once did a character bio on him. Basically his father was a misogynist too and he saw his dad treat his mom horribly, so he mistook treating women badly for showing them affection. Plus there's the poor role model idea. I also had a theory he was angry at his mom for dying when he was young so that may have contributed."

Interesting point, I too kind of thought that either this was passed on from or was learned by him from his father.

"Why would being a misogynist mean you don't want sex with a woman? That makes no sense. You think your sex drive goes away because you hate women??? You think your sexual preference changes??? Plus having sex with women can be revenge on them--you break their hearts. And meaningless sex can be a way to fill a void in your life."

That may indeed be true, but I have known some people who in itself found sex gross and I just really wondered how people can be capable of/bring themselves to have sex with someone who they hate and how, even if their intentions are bad, they would even know to break their hearts amd what kind of void would meaningless sex just like that fill in a person's life if he is not attracted to the person doing it.

"It's more complicated than that. There is no "100% opinion". In life there is no 100% right or 100% wrong in almost any case. Shades of grey in almost everything."

OK, so rules and conventions are more or less what we make, human beings, and nature doesn't really create and dictate rules and laws that prove - "Yeah, there really IS 100% correct opinion, isn't there?"

"Women commit rape and it happens a lot more than people will ever acknowledge. This has nothing to do with the Frank character but I'll bite. Rape is one of the few things that is 100% wrong. If someone commits rape it should ALWAYS be prosecuted. Same with cold blooded murder. There is no excuse for either EVER. I don't see how anyone can argue this."

True, and murder and other crimes, as history has proven throughout both life and fiction. I only wonder why T.J. Mackey character HASN'T said it when he made his speech about defending men and giving examples of women doing the same or other things - i.e. lying, cheating, manipulating men etc. Maybe he didn't want to cause unnecessary controversial debates like that at a public meeting? But then again, he did so in OTHER ways, so?

And yes, I do agree that aforementioned deed and crime is terrible. And apparently females could also be guity of it. I wonder though if T.J. Mackey ever considered it, and what DID he think of that scene from "Thursday" (1998)? On a remotely DIFFERENT level, I find it astonishing the double standards people have displayed on this subject, look at how on Thursday's board men say they would love for a woman to do that to them, and yet if that was the gender opposite standard case, they will go nothing BUT mad. Then again, in the film "Super" (2010), the lead hero has not only forgiven the girl who raped him, but was devastated and heartbroken when she got shot and killed as if he lost a loved one, and took revenge on 10+ heavily armed men for her killing. Yet he had ZERO trouble killing a man who attempted to do the same to his wife without any remorse. Double standards? Strange?

Having spoken about that and also in the film, but this time from a traditional case -

How come the TV presenter was never reported to the police by Claudia for molesting her, and did he really actually do that? Its heavily implied he WAS guilty, but not revealed 100%.

"We are lead to believe that he was at the time. I suspect he was a misogynist as well. He probably was a product of his times (though that does not excuse it). He regretted it though, so he wasn't all horrible (again shades of grey)."

Kind of true. And judging by how he spoke even on his death bed, with swearing and whatnot, he did seem to have been spoiled a lot at the time.

"Women and men should be punished the same. However, revenge should not be considered."

Possibly, but did it ever cross HIS mind like that, what did HE possibly think on the issue?

And with regards to revenge, let's face it, we have seen PLENTY of times in films where MALES get in all violent ways or just via standard killing revenge exacted on them for horrible misdeeds they made, not just killing of someone but acts that are humiliating, including sexual offenses, usually against women, sometimes against men and whoever not, with no problem.

But if the perpetrator in question is a female, with rare and usually not that extreme exceptions, such vengeance was practically never exacted. Sure, there were cases because they happened to be too clever to either track down or manipulate others in believing their own stories. But in many other cases, it is because people in general, men and women, sort of believe that men are stronger than women, even bad ones, and I can understand the difference as such. So maybe revenge should NOT be considered, but it can be and often is.

I only really wondered here what Tom Cruise's character may have thought on that, and would he feel Elizabeth bathory should've died painfully for murdering those virgins like that?

"
He IS a misogynist in the same way a "I have black friends" racist is still a racist. It's complicated, but a person who says the things he does is ALWAYS a misogynist. Intent isn't the point. Sexual desires are inconsequential, they are 100% biological. I don't know why you think they have anything to do with being a misogynist. Misogynists often have MORE sex with women and in fact having more sex is a SIGN of being one in most cases."

Yeah, so basically, human beings are not perfect and often have some exceptional qualities that doesn't diminish their bad deeds if they have or do bad deeds. And one may have black friends for other maybe reasons and no one is 100% good or 100% awful like that.

And hate towards people while wrong based on their natural qualities/genders is often complicated when it comes to analyzing the whys of it, as in, people hating people isn't the same as hating food and whatnot just like that.

By the way, in the movie "Ex Drummer" (2007), there are male characters that are mysoginists that still sleep with women and often even hate other men, or who dislike homosexuals but still enjoy homosexual sex. So I suppose its not that simple really and humans are complex as to why and how they have on one hand unacceptable hate and on the other a desire to still get involved with someone intimately.

Human beings are interesting and complex creatures indeed.

reply

On a side note - I don't tend to have sexual urges at all, is that natural?

The greatest trick the Devil has ever pulled was convincing the world he didn't exist!

reply

Interesting thread.
Human sexuality is a many faceted subject.
Mostly, it is about smell and reproducing the species.
However, it can be confused by subjects like power (domination), humiliation,etc.....
IMhO, "Love" is something exclusive to the female and its offspring.

I had to crash the Honda....

reply

Basically, besides Tom Cruise's character in the film, what I was wondering about beyond all this is why mysoginy is considered wrong and highly unacceptable whereas misandry generally ISN'T, and why as a civilized society we often hold a far bigger grudge against men who do terrible deeds but not as much if women may do same things however rare, and why not only real life but many movies throughout cinema history have reflected this?

And how do you get a grip on all of this as a NORMAL HUMAN BEING who, I hope, is civilized enough and understands the concepts as well as tangeants and tendencies of JUSTICE?

I also wonder if Tom Cruise's character has ever given any of this much thought, even if he hasn't spoken too much about it all? Like, what would he do for instance if a woman sexually harrassed him or even tried to you know what, yeah, a bit like in "Disclosure" (1994) - would he react to it with madness and would he feel destroyed by it? Or would he somehow shrug it off?

What if a woman tried to kill him and he just HAD to kill her in self defense, would he feel some sort of guilty conscience over it, like Leonardo DiCaprio's character in "Shutter Island" (2010)?

And how would he deal if he say was FALSELY ACCUSED in similar cases of something very bad?

Basically, are men and women overall that different or are they mostly the same as human beings?

The greatest trick the Devil has ever pulled was convincing the world he didn't exist!

reply

IMhO, "Love" is something exclusive to the female and its offspring.


Disagreed. I've loved many people. Many that I'm willing to give my life for. I'm not female.


Also I think that you will soon realize this is my signature.

reply

Depends on how one defines what's natural I suppose. Individuals who are "asexual" in a sense, could be considered outside the norm but I personally wouldn't say it's "unnatural." I feel many people define what is natural presumptuously, founded in their skewed perception of everyday experiences.

Some concepts are easier described as natural vs unnatural than others and superficially people could argue that sexual urges are natural (proliferation of the species, as an excuse to be slutty, etc). But what is natural is also about perception, what may be natural to one person may be unnatural to another and vice versa.

You are who you are and as long as you can recognize your self, can address your physical and mental needs, and can fulfill those needs, then it's all good. If you don't tend to have sexual urges I wouldn't call it unnatural, I'd call it lucky, God knows my urges have gotten me in trouble in the past.

reply

Yes.

Also I think that you will soon realize this is my signature.

reply

"Yes" to what door?

The greatest trick the Devil has ever pulled was convincing the world he didn't exist!

reply

So I've read through this thread and I was going to share some thoughts and point in the direction of a few references which might have been helpful.

I mean this with no disrespect, but I found your analysis and the questions you posed a little bit unusual. I don't usually do this, but I took a peak at your posting history just out of curiosity.

I quickly noticed that you seem to have a frequent pattern of posting about sex crimes and morality, and how the two topics relate.

I don't know anything about your, your history, or your pathology. Maybe it's just a random obsession of yours. But there seems to be something going on here. Have you considered speaking to a therapist? Maybe that might help you with the issues you might be struggling with.

reply