MovieChat Forums > Kuch Kuch Hota Hai (1998) Discussion > such a stupid film!!!!

such a stupid film!!!!

posted 11 years ago by jahangirhussain74
18 replies | jump to latest

KKHH is plain stupid at best. how can a film that is so illogical win so many praises? I know that no plot is perfect, but KKHH went too far in terms of illogicality. I don't understand why would Rani write a letter to her yet-to-be-born baby to get SRK and Kajol married when she (her yet-to-be-born baby) turns 8 years old. How can an 8-year-old girl handle such a big responsibility? Wouldn't it be more sensible to tell her mother-in-law (Farida Jalal) to do the job? And how come Rani was so confident that Kajol won't get married in those 8 years? I mean in those 8 years anything could have happened to Kajol. Sheer stupidity!!! that's what happens when you let a young, naive director like Karan Johar direct a film!!!!

reply

[–] itssmithaabraham 11 years ago

other than the stupid meaningless story,the movie was filled with overacting by the lead and supporting cast

reply

[–] Catgurl22 10 years ago

Calling this film "stupid" is a gross understatement and an insult to all the stupid people of this world.

Mr McGee, don't make me angry. You wouldn't like me when I'm angry!

reply

[–] Planet-38 8 years ago

I really wanted to like this, but, I have to agree; I found the plot ridiculous and the whole tale overlong. Plus, I kept hoping that big Anjali would marry the guy that loved her first, Aman, not settle for being second best. How could she not always feel like the consolation prize?

"Arguing with idiots is like trying to play chess with a pigeon..."

reply

[–] Stratego 8 years ago

What the fish?! I love this movie! The kid was annoying, but other than that, it's darn entertaining. The plot's a little silly, but that's to be expected of a romantic comedy from Bollywood.

The idea is that Rani clearly could see that Anjali would never get over SRK and that divine powers would make sure she would not marry anyone else in the meantime. Just look what happened, when she almost did. Rani may also have understood that her mother-in-law wasn't the type of person to do the job by herself, unlike her daughter whom she was able to train for years through her letters.

reply

[–] jahangirhussain74 8 years ago

This just proves how big of an idiot you are that you're not able to see some big blemishes in the script of KKHH. Rani's plan was to get SRK and Kajol hitched after 8 years when her daughter turns 8. How in the world did Rani know that in those 8 years Kajol won't get married and in those years anything could have happened to Kajol. She could be dead, she could have moved somewhere far away and you name it. It seems like Rani is a goddess that everything goes the way she planned. If Rani simply told her mother-in-law to get SRK and Kajol married right after her daughter was born, then her daughter would not have known that Kajol is not her biological mom and even if she found out she would have been cool about it and she could have accepted Kajol as her own mother rather than after those 8 years of her life and seeing her father getting hitched to another woman. It simply doesn't make sense to show a little girl doing all the matchmaking of her father with another woman. Karan Johar could have simply left that to Farida Jalal and the movie could have still turned out the way it did.

reply

[–] Stratego 8 years ago

Wow, it's clear you're the idiot for calling other people an idiot because they don't agree with you and taking a silly romantic comedy so seriously. Have you never seen a movie from this genre in your life before?

You can repeat the same sh!t all over again, but I already gave you an answer. Rani had no idea what was going to happen, but should she just decide not to write the letters just in case Kajol was dead? She just wanted to reunite two people who loved each other and in her opinion were destined to be together. And who says she expected her daughter to do it NOW? Being 8 years old she was old enough to understand and at least start trying. And the mother-in-law did not seem like the person to go look for Kajol for herself, especially not while her son was still mourning his dead wife. She only went along because of her granddaughter. Now move on and try to learn what respect is.

reply

[–] jahangirhussain74 8 years ago

whatever you say, it seems like you're born with a thick head that nothing goes inside it. you will always be an idiot in my eyes and don't lecture me on respect. an idiot like you should be treated like an idiot.

reply

[–] Stratego 8 years ago

Keep telling that to yourself, it only proves that you're the idiot.

reply

[–] jahangirhussain74 8 years ago

an idiot always thinks other people are idiots. actually, you and karan johar belong to the same school of idiocy!

reply

[–] Stratego 8 years ago

an idiot always thinks other people are idiots.

Yes, and you're an example of that.

reply

[–] jahangirhussain74 8 years ago

you're right i'm an idiot for arguing with an idiot like you. anyways, i'll call it quits now. *beep* off!

reply

[–] Stratego 8 years ago

I'm glad you finally understand that you've lost. Bye!

reply

[–] jahangirhussain74 8 years ago

i haven't accepted defeat u idiot. it's just that I have better things to do than to argue with an idiot like u. and whatever u say won't change my opinion about the plot of this movie. the plot of this movie is still the most stupid and illogical in my opinion.

reply

[–] Stratego 8 years ago

Haha, I thought you had called it quits! You just keep proving your own point that you're an idiot.

reply

[–] jahangirhussain74 8 years ago

you're the idiot for arguing with me. almost everyone agreed with me that it's a stupid film except for you. so you're the idiot. i called it quits but doesn't mean that i have accepted defeat.

reply

[–] Stratego 8 years ago

 Still not done?! Three people is hardly "everyone". Are you set out to prove you're an idiot?! LOL

reply

[–] varunthedragon-931-766034 7 years ago

It makes no logical sense. No romance movie does. It's not supposed to. If you apply logic, they're not the same naive college kids they once were. There would be more responsibility, more reluctance, more everything. It's more about sentiment. That being said, I'm not fond of how melodramatic these movies tend to get

reply

[–] Stratego (29209) 4 years ago

🖕🖕🖕

reply