MovieChat Forums > Luna Papa (2000) Discussion > Hey! nobody here yet?!

Hey! nobody here yet?!


Anyone who loves this film too? It's currently #3 in my top movies list.

"In case I don't see ya, good afternoon, good evening, and good night!"

reply

I love it, too. I saw it maybe 3 or 4 years ago and found it amazing. It is so utterly different, not only from mainstream Hollywood, but from the European film tradition as well. It's worlds apart, in terms of imagination, settings, plot, underlying philosophy, concept of entertainment.

Like somebody else noted, I too was continuously taken aback, the development was totally unpredictable; the pace was, for a non-Hollywood production, really fast. Although it is basically a comedy, I found the characters credible enough, the dialogues quirky, the photography stunning, the scenery breath-taking, the situations both weird and plausible. The young Mamlakat is funny and highly spirited, in addition to being eye-catching, and also the rest of the cast is excellent.

I have seen a few movies in my rather long life, but this one stands out in most respects. I certainly rate it among my all-time favourites and will definitely buy the dvd, although it appears to be currently available only with German subtitles.

reply

I just saw this film and loved. it's cool it was filmed in tajikistan...i lived in kyrgyzstan for three months and many of the things depicted in the film remind me of that experience.

reply

my favourite shot in the entire film is the close up on the father's face after he finds out his daughter is pregnant.

can anyone explain the ending to me?

reply

one have to keep in mind that the story is told by the baby so that's why things seem so unreal. It's a child vision of the world. So that's just how the child explain how her mother fled with him (of course in "reality" it was more "normal")

About your other post, I recommend movies by Aktan Abdykalykov if you want to find some good Khyrghiz films...

Please visit my profile & me for my unsolved researches - always new ones! Thanks

reply

I just loved it. Is fantastic and shows you how the dreams can take off the bad things of your life, like the end: So mystic and beautiful. Just a dream came true.

"I roar and I rampage and I got bloody satisfaction" B.K



reply

I saw the film last weekend, I liked it, liked the girl very much. Every time she said 'Salam aleikum' to the abducted actors I would burst out laughing.

But I had also noticed on the films listing that it was produced by Europeans, and I always weary of such films (produced and made by Europeans or Europe based film makers). When you see a film, for example, set in Afghanistan and it’s about how woman want to be 'exactly' like European women I wonder is that the ideas of real women in Afghanistan or is that some alien thought...

The ending was really week and I think that is very connected to the ideas in the film and the fact they couldn't settle them with reality so they had to flee to fantasy!

reply

I think you must keep in mind that the director, writer and composer are from these countries so they might have a lot more influence on the story, messages and atmosphere than European producers and technicians. Moreover I don't feel that "European way of life" admiration in the film. Just about theater and Shakespeare maybe. And some details. And a criticism of army and so on. But generally it's a movie that stays in its part of the world. Actually you also have to keep in mind that Khudojnasarov invented a fake country. He says in interviews about the film that it's inspired by several Central Asian countries. So in that film, you can' really expect a true cultural athenticity.

As for the end, I don't think it's weak at all. And I disagree with you: on the contrary I think it keeps its non-European AND non-realistic atmosphere during the whole film. And that's why it's my favourite film ever!
(see also my other post above about my explanation of the end)


Please visit my profile & me for my unsolved researches - always new ones! Thanks

reply

So we meet again jraf(!) (you're the one who once gave me the idea to put a "help" sign in my signature)
I only saw a part of this movie but it looked pretty interesting (people in the west don't know that much about central asia)

reply

you're the one who once gave me the idea to put a "help" sign in my signature

Oh yeah! I had forgotten your name (I am a lot less present on imdb now since I discovered Wikipedia and Facebook!) but I remember that I "inspired" someone! Glad to "see" you.

people in the west don't know that much about central asia

Well you're unfortunately right. It's quite obscure for occidental societies. I'm lucky because I'm about to live in Uzbekistan for one or two years! Maybe I'll discover other Uzbek films...


Please visit my profile & me for my unsolved researches - always new ones! Thanks

reply

I like it, I saw it 2wice in Jerusalem when it came out!

reply