MovieChat Forums > Arthur (1996) Discussion > That episode where Arthur bullied Sue El...

That episode where Arthur bullied Sue Ellen


It was garbage
FFirst of all it was a little teasing with her sweater
Second of all ARTHUR IS RIGHT. HE GOT TEASED CONSISTENTLY IN THE OLD DAYS BUT NOBODY CARED THEN
Why is Sue Ellen crying? She knows judo n karate. She owned binky and she'd destroy arthur

Weird episode

reply

It was a bad episode. Sue Ellen and especially Arthur were both very out of character.

"I ate a pear. I ate three pairs." - Lizzie Borden

reply

I thought the episode was great. I'm assuming that the characterization in that episode was meant to be different to strengthen the moral. They handled this a lot better than in "Arthur's Big Hit."

"Long live your idols, may they never be your rivals"

reply

Hey, like I said before, I'm a fan of when people act "out of character", because people do that sometimes. That being said, it'd be nice if it were to have some sort of justification. Arthur isn't the type of guy to indiscriminately "bully" someone, and Sue Ellen sure as hell isn't the type to take that kind of crap. It's sad that such nonsensical "casting", if you will, must serve as such a distraction for what could, if handled correctly, have been a fairly good latter-day episode on this sadly ever-more-problematic subject.

reply

I liked the message of the episode that anybody can be a bully and anybody can be the victim. Though maybe it would have been better to use Jenna who can defend herself but is more shy than Sue Ellen.

Houston permission to masturbate in the airlock chamber?

reply

Hey, like I said before, I'm a fan of when people act "out of character", because people do that sometimes. That being said, it'd be nice if it were to have some sort of justification.


But that's what being OOC means. When characters do things without there being reason behind it.

Arthur isn't the type of guy to indiscriminately "bully" someone, and Sue Ellen sure as hell isn't the type to take that kind of crap. It's sad that such nonsensical "casting", if you will, must serve as such a distraction for what could, if handled correctly, have been a fairly good latter-day episode on this sadly ever-more-problematic subject.


Given that Sue Ellen had no fear of fighting or dishing out verbal assaults against a bully with a reputation (Binky) in season 1, it is jarring to see her act like a shrinking violet over Arthur's comments. I did rationalize it as Sue Ellen feeling hurt that her friend (and...possible crush, according to that episode with the diary) is maliciously taunting her, because I'm sure that would hurt anyone, and add to the tension of the situation more. However, after re-watching A Bully for Binky after years of not having seen it, I have come to the conclusion that she probably wouldn't have taken that crap from him. Maybe they should've used Fern instead. She's shyer, more sensitive, and is established as being moodier at times. Something like this might've affected her more deeply.

As for Arthur being the bully, I could buy it more than Sue Ellen being the victim. Sometimes harmless teasing can evolve into harassment, and some people are unaware of it. And sometimes spite can cause people to lash out like Arthur did toward her in this episode. I've seen good people succumb to this, and it can be disheartening. I think having the bullying come from, say, one of the Tough Customers might've lessened the point that anyone can go too far and become a bully if they don't mind their behavior.

reply

Basically Sue Ellen and Fern switched bodies

Ever since Sue Ellen's original voice actor left the character has not been the same

Also Buster supposedly outgrew Bionic Bunny but in other eps..............

reply

I would guess that aside from showing that anyone can be the victim, it was meant to show that such actions are more hurtful coming from a friend, someone you trust and count on. And perhaps, considering the Sue Ellen character, it would be easier for her to beat up the school bully for hurting her or others than it would be for her to hurt Arthur, because even though he was bullying her, he had been her friend. Someone in such a position would probably feel very betrayed and conflicted. Not to mention, martial arts tend to emphasize self-defence, so beating up someone for verbal harassment would never be condoned.

reply

I can't watch this episode because it's just so bad.

Arthur has been bullied before, so you'd think that he would know better. It would have made more sense if the bully was someone like Francine or Muffy. Besides, didn't we already have an "anti-bullying" themed episode?

SIND SIE DAS ESSEN NEIN WIR SIND DER JÄGER

reply

Well, someone who is bullied sometimes lashes out and becomes a bully for various reasons, though in this case Arthur doesn't really qualify as such a person. Arthur is more the oblivious bully. Someone who engages in bullying without realizing that his behaviour has crossed over from "all in good fun" to potentially seriously damaging to the other person. He doesn't seem to realize how cruel he is being.

reply

Well, you get you bullied, you become a bully. That WAS an odd episode.

"Last week?!? The school burnt down six years ago"-Mr. Strickland (Back To The Future Part II)

reply

Well, you get you bullied, you become a bully.


Uh, not always.

reply

Regardless it was still a strange episode.

Lars Ulrich, James Hetfield, and Kirk Hammett of Metallica ship Discord and Fluttershy

reply

I agree, for starters,

- Sue Ellen is known for being the "tough badass" one who knows karate.

- She didn't let Binkys bullying bother her, so why would Arthur's teasing bother her.

- Plus Francine and Muffy and hypocrites for calling Arthur out when they've bullied people plenty of times.

- Francine made fun of his glasses and baby teeth and never apologized.

- Muffy made fun of Francine's footed pijamas calling them "babyish"

reply