movie holds up because


you didnt really need the twist ending, it was just the cherry on top.

the film was compelling and concluded satisfactionally before

reply

I totally agree. I can still watch this movie today, even though I've seen it a dozen times.

reply

While the drama’s a little tedious, it’s refreshing compared to modern blockbusters with their idiotic explosions every five minutes. Furthermore, the film is aesthetically pleasing, which is helped by the unique Fall locations (Philadelphia & areas nearby) and corresponding architecture & statuary. Lastly, it is interesting to view the flick to see how Shyamalan is able to successfully hide the twist.

reply

The acting is solid throughout by both Osment and Collette, especially when Cole gives his mom the message for his dead grandmother.

reply

No special effects. Society (- a cell phone) looks like they did 10 or 20 or 30 years ago...

reply