MovieChat Forums > The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (2002) Discussion > There’s no way that Gandalf says ‘bandy ...

There’s no way that Gandalf says ‘bandy crooked words’ at Edoras.


He is supposed to but it’s unintelligible.

reply

It's a perfectly cromulent expression.

Seriously, it's not an uncommon phrase in older literature, and quite recognizable to anyone reasonably well-read.

reply

Speaking of well read, you obviously didn’t read what i wrote very well.

reply

I took your post to mean that the phrase "bandy crooked words" made no sense. But if you were simply saying that the words weren't spoken clearly enough to be understood, then I did in fact misread you, and I owe you an apology, which I'm happy to give.

reply

Just for using the word cromulent, I can forgive you most anything. You just embiggened my joy today.

reply

OK fair enough, no apology necessary.

reply

I understood it upon my first viewing so I don't get your point

reply

You read the book first.

reply

years before I saw the movie, so I wasn't even prepared to seek out similarities or differences from book to movie, so my original point stands. What was so weird about what Gandalf said?

reply

I was initially confused by the word "ere", used frequently in these movies.

reply