Is Aragorn Racist?


Why with WORMTONGUE Aragorn urges to stop king Theoden from killing this trator who show no mercy even to the women and children of Rohan and advice Saruman to send his warg riders to kill them and spare his life,

But in the battle of helms deep Aragorn say to the warriors about the ORCS:
"Show them no mercy... for you shall receive none!"

Do I smell RACISM in the air? Is It because they are ORCS?

reply

This is usually a sign of trolling but, in case somebody takes it seriously:

Grima was at the mercy of his captors and the full reach of his treachery was unknown at the time. The film makes it look as if the information about the weakness at Helm's Deep hadn't been conveyed already but the book makes that seem unlikely. Grima's salivating over the "defenseless women and children" was a movie-only moment, obviously designed to ramp up the tension.

Aragorn's "Show them no mercy... for you shall receive none!" was in rerence to an attacking army, not a defenseless captive.

reply

Aragorn is not being racist. The Orcs are an attacking army, not a helpless prisoner. And he is absolutely correct: the defenders can expect no mercy from their attackers and cannot afford to show any in battle.

"If I'm going to have a past, I prefer it to be multiple choice!" - The Joker

reply

You mean, a good character in Lord of the Rings might have a special dislike toward evil creatures who were bred for nothing but destruction? :P All the good guys hated the Orcs. They were intrinsically bad. It's not like in real life; in real life, you can't breed different kinds of creatures and end up with sentient beings that are literally incapable of doing anything good.

reply

Yep the Orcs were monsters. It is a fantasy store where there are creatures that are meant for nothing about destruction. Not everything is a parallel to real life. Some stories are just good old fashion good vs evil fun.

reply

Interestingly, Tolkien seems to have regretted that he made the orchs appear that way.


J. R. R. Tolkien's Middle-earth stories have evil creatures mutated from natural ones by Dark Lord Morgoth: Orcs, Trolls, Dragons, Werewolves, Wargs, etc. However, as a devout Catholic who believed in spiritual salvation, the idea of a race of inherently or irredeemably evil creatures was one of Tolkien's major sticking points with his own work. He spent much of the latter part of his life as a writer trying to justify it. He never did come up with an explanation that satisfied him.
Orcs: In The Silmarillion, the Elves theorize that Orcs were Elves tortured and corrupted by Morgoth, and in The Lord of the Rings Treebeard voices a similar theory about Trolls being bred as a mockery of Ents. Both of these are beliefs of characters, which are never directly confirmed by the author. Another idea was that Orcs are generally just Human tribes and are "evil" precisely because of Sauron and Morgoth's magic. After the One Ring is destroyed, they become feral and scatter in all directions.

These later explanations of Orcs can be seen as an exploration of institutionalized abuse and slavery. While they may be a "species" genetically distinct from their Elf and/or Human ancestors, their evil cultures resulted from millennia of slavery, Religion of Evil, and deliberate corruption. They are less inherently evil than a race that's been warped by external forces into cannon fodder. Tolkien even wrote "deep in their dark hearts the Orcs loathed the Master (Morgoth) whom they served in fear, the maker only of their misery."

Perhaps the most tragic and frightening thing about Orcs and Trolls is that we can never know what they would be like if Morgoth and Sauron hadn't ruined them, or if any of them were able to grow up in a less cruel culture. They're never given the opportunity to be anything but evil. They're raised in cultures that encourage hoarding and greed and the differences between them incite the violent tendencies bred into them by the Dark Lords. In an Orc society, cooperation would reduce your own chance of survival in a dangerous situation (i.e. leave your partner to the wolves and escape on your own). Sauron's propaganda also convinced them that their enemies, particularly Elves, were even crueler than Orcs, to discourage them from ever surrendering in battle. It's worth noting that the Forces of Light are essentially waging an extermination war against the Orcs and likely wouldn't know what to do with any that actually surrendered peacefully.

In one letter, Tolkien points out that some Orcs display courage and tribal loyalty if nothing else, and that they wouldn't have been able to function as well if they were completely evil. And he was generally quite good at giving individual Orcs distinct personalities. (This is touched on in the animated version of The Return of the King, where some orcs sing that they don't want to go to war but their officers and Sauron tell them to.)

reply

[deleted]

Aragon is racist against Orcs? I thought I've heard it all, but this one takes the cake. Lol!!! And this folks, is why Political Correctness is such a cancer.

reply

Aragorn is not racist. he is an awesome warrior. he fights with passion. he kills those orcs and wargs with strong mighty powers,

reply

A Racist is anyone who gets the upper hand in a discussion on any subject with a SJW

reply

Anyway, the correct term would not be racist but speciest, since orcs are not a different race but a different species of intelligent being. If Doctor McCoy says Spock is a green-blooded, pointy-eared hobgoblin, for example, he is being speciest instead of racist.

reply

Aragorn is a fucking dirty racist. Instead of opening the gates of Gondor and celebrating the diversity becoming enriched with the wonderful Orc way of life, he opposed diversity using the violence against Orcs immigrants. Aragorn was just a deplorable Gondor supremacist.

Gandalf was another racist supremacist, by the way, that opposed multiculturalism instead of embracing diversity and cultural enrichment as the wise Saruman did.

Shame on them :(

reply

rofl

reply