MovieChat Forums > Alice in Wonderland (1999) Discussion > I prefer this one.

I prefer this one.

posted 14 years ago by Movie-Whore
7 replies | jump to latest

I saw the new Alice In wonderland last night, and to be honest I really didn't care for it.

This adaptation is still my favorite.

[–] stardustfairy85 14 years ago

i completely agree!! Marting Short is the best Mad Hatter! Johnny Depp missed the mark for me.

[–] narcolepticsloth 14 years ago

I second this. Burton's version seemed to be trying too hard...

[–] 14 years ago

[deleted]

[–] DrLectersGirl 13 years ago

I like this one so much better than the new one.

"Not in a thousand years? That's my girl." Hannibal

[–] weaverbill 13 years ago

So do I.

So many films, so little time

[–] craig-353 13 years ago

Funny enough this is exactly what I came on this forum to post myself. The Tim Burton one just felt wrong. Like they were trying to put a new spin on an old classic and what they came up with was just... weak!

[–] KristenStewartForever 8 years ago

Short and Depp are the two best.