A lack of tact?


I have great respect for Michael Apted, but did anyone else feel that he seems to lack a bit of tact? Some of his questions throughout the series come across as really judgmental/inappropriate/rude...but I realize that sometimes this is what makes for a good interview--and often the answers to the questions are insightful ones. And I understand that interview questions are also not always based on personal opinions but rather trying to project the questions/judgments the audience might have.

All that to say, the questions are understandable, but what bothered me a bit was some of the commentary. While he makes it clear that he has a relationship with his collaborators, he also discusses then at times like subjects rather than individuals who might be listening to the commentary--revealing more personal behind-the-scenes information they may not have been comfortable with. Plus, his discussion of his two misjudgments in projecting the future of Tony as well as Nick's marriage--while he admits that he was mistaken to do that--makes me question his motives/attitude toward some of the earlier documentaries. His attitude at times seemed a bit condescending, even. He swears that they bent over backwards to protect the privacy of each family, but I felt some of the information given in the commentary contradicted that, especially when he discusses why various individuals might have been embarrassed about appearing or a spouse was 'unsupportive' (I don't see how not wanting to be made into a subject inevitably being analyzed by sociologists is unsupportive of art).

reply

Yeah, I've noticed that some times he forgets that the documentary subjects are actually people.

I thought his comments on his original thoughts of Bruce being gay were the most severely rude.

reply

I think this is why some of the subjects have a hard time participating in the film.

Jackie apparently has had a tumultuous relationship with him. They even argued in "49 Up."

John refuses to be interviewed by him.

Suzy resents the invasion and Apted has said he believes "49 Up" was her last.

Still, for every person that's not willing to put up with him, there are three that are.

reply

It's true, he does seem to have a distance. But seriously, how can't you? This is, after all, a study - as crude as it sounds. If those were his friends how could he stop himself from saving Neil, for example?

Ultimately, you're right, but I can't see how else the experiment could work out.

reply

Big deal. His awareness and directness with it to ask the questions that we, the viewer, might be thinking of in relation to each person is part of his strength and what makes this series compelling. It's obvious from how some comment that Apted manages to balance friendliness and familiarity with a scientific eye.

A taut thread ties her to me from which hangs the question 'can I trust you?'

reply

He does seem rather malicious when he asks women in their 40s whether they want to have more children...

reply

He laughs at some answers too.

reply