Do you think Livingston's character did the right thing? I think that he had a tough decision to make and he did the right thing by waiting to see which one he like the most. He probably could have played it a little better with each of them, but overall he did it right....and picked the right one in my opinion.
sharei don't think they developed either female character for it to really matter...i like amanda peets line when she calls him a 'silly goose'! the writing was so bad.
"imitate a cat puking..."
I think Carlito's reasoning is good but final answer is wrong. The issue is how the Livingston's character handles the situation, not which girl he choses.